Skip to main content

Permanent Impermanence: or, How the Fudge Did That Fossilize?

Imagine the weather turning to stone...

This article was published in Scientific American’s former blog network and reflects the views of the author, not necessarily those of Scientific American


Geology might not be quite as weird as quantum physics, but it's got its moments.

There's a great many weird things to choose from, but I'll tell you what warps my mind: seeing things we normally think of as temporary preserved forever in stone.

Image shows a slab of red sandstone, propped up against a sandstone cliff, surrounded by dead branches. The sandstone bears distinct ripple marks, looking like a piece of riverbed raised up.
Ripples in the Moenkopi Formation. Credit: Daniel Mayer  (CC BY-SA 2.5)
 


On supporting science journalism

If you're enjoying this article, consider supporting our award-winning journalism by subscribing. By purchasing a subscription you are helping to ensure the future of impactful stories about the discoveries and ideas shaping our world today.


Two hundred and forty million years ago, waves left ripples in soft sands and silts.  Currents worked and reworked these sediments, and you'd think that something so ephemeral would be wiped away long before the ancient mud flats and river beds turned to stone.  But this time, other sediments swept in and buried the ripples whole.  They lay there under their blanket for hundreds of millions of years, as ages passed, an orogeny lifted the plateau, time turned ancient muds to rock, and erosion wore the blanket away.  Now here we are, in the middle of a desert, looking at the echo of wetter days.

I'm sorry, but that's just bloody weird.

Walk around Wupatki National Monument, and you'll see ancient ripples exposed in the red sandstones of the Moenkopi Formation.

Image shows a slab of red sandstone with ripple marks. It's partially covered in pebbles, and cracked in several places.
Ripples, Moenkopi Formation, Wupatki National Monument. Credit: Dana Hunter
 

Ripple marks in rocks tell geologists all sorts of things about where and how they formed: whether by wind or water, what direction the wind blew or the water flowed, what an environment long vanished was like.  Just little ripples, most ordinary things in the world, suddenly extraordinary.

And it gets weirder.

Image shows a reddish-pink sandstone boulder jumbled in with other assorted boulders. The edges of it show a crazed impression of mud cracks.
Mud cracks, unidentified sedimentary rocks, Richmond Beach, WA. Credit: Dana Hunter
 

Where I grew up, in northern Arizona, we got to see plenty of mud cracks.  And the thing about them was, they never lasted.  We'd have a torrential rain (in Arizona, when it rains, it usually pours).  Then it would get dry again (in Arizona, when it gets dry, it gets dry).  And then, a few days later, the hardened mud went back to being ordinary dirt again, worked over by wind, maybe a bit more water, and probably quite a variety of biological beings, all nice and soft and not a crack in sight.  They didn't last.

So imagine my surprise when I learned that sometimes, if the mud cracks get covered by a nice layer of sand or silt, they can sometimes last forever.

Image shows a red sandstone boulder on a sandy beach. The mudcracks are filled in with a lighter, sandier rock.
Another set of mud cracks, unidentified sedimentary rocks, Richmond Beach, WA. Credit: Dana Hunter
 

And if the sediment that covers the mud cracks is a bit different from the sediment the mud cracks formed in, you get some really wild contrasts.

Mud cracks are a dead giveaway that the place these sedimentary rocks formed in suffered from wet and dry cycles.  (I wish these told us more, but they're in boulders ripped out of their context, so I haven't got the slightest clue what formation they're from.  But if you ever make it down to Richmond Beach in Seattle, wander a bit down the beach toward the spot where the train tracks bend, and have yourself a look at the severely out-of-place mauve rocks shoring up the railway bed.)

And it gets weirder.  And wormier.

Image shows a slab of red sandstone sitting on a rounded boulder of white limestone. The sandstone has fat tubes running through it in all directions.
Burrow casts, Moenkopi Formation, Meteor Crater. Credit: Dana Hunter
 

These little delights are burrow casts.  Some enterprising animals wormed their way down into the sediments way back when the Moenkopi Formation didn't realize what it was destined for.  Then something, maybe a flood, washed a bunch of mud and sand down into the poor dears' homes, making a cast.  These had a slightly more exciting life than some in the formation.  Not only did they get elevated by thousands of feet over millions of years and turned to stone, but then, about fifty thousand years ago, a maclargehuge lump of iron and nickel fell out of space and tossed them around like a salad.  Exciting times.

But that's not the mind-warping, worldview-changing, weirdest bloody thing I've ever seen.  This is:

Image shows a white piece of sandstone dotted with pits caused by a long-ago rain shower.
Fossil raindrop impressions in the Horton Bluff Formation. Credit: Rygel, M.C. (CC BY-SA 3.0)
 

Raindrops.  Fossil freaking raindrops.  Can you think of anything less likely to survive millions of years and who knows what vagaries of erosion than a raindrop?  Such a delicate thing, such a tiny thing, a memory of a brief shower, so long ago, living to tell the tale.

Okay, so I haven't seen anything like that personally.  Chris Rowan has.  I've seen structures like these in various formations around Arizona without realizing what I was looking at.  Figured it was just a bit of weird weathering.  Well, in a way, it is.  But the weather happened millions of years ago, when rain fell on the smooth surface of a mud flat, or the shifting sands of a dune.

Geology, my friends, is weird, and wonderful.

 

(A version of this post originally appeared at En Tequila Es Verdad)