Skip to main content

Bob Milne: Four Songs, One Mind.

This article was published in Scientific American’s former blog network and reflects the views of the author, not necessarily those of Scientific American


Every musician's dream is to travel the world, be critically acclaimed, and be able to listen to four different pieces of music simultaneously.

Alright, so maybe that last part is a bit more of a pipe dream than the first two. However, this highly unusual simultaneous listening ability is a skill that ragtime pianist Bob Milne possesses. This ability is so uncommon that it lead to Milne being a topic of study for Penn State neuroscientist Kerstin Bettermann.

Milne was playing a gig at a California social club when he caught the eye of a neuroscientist who had once been Bettermann's colleague.

Milne said was showing people how he could play in three different time signatures at once -- 3/4, 4/4, and 5/4. Playing one on his left hand, another with the thumb of his right hand, and the last with the rest of his right hand.

Keeping track of notes aside, to put it in some perspective, here's how tough that is. Try counting to three over and over in your head, keeping a steady beat: 1,2,3-1,2,3. Now start counting to four at the same time, over and over. (It should be impossible by now.) Now keep a five-count beat on top of the other two.

Impossible? For most people, yes. In fact, the doctor there that day thought it was supposed to be impossible for everyone.

“He starts yelling, 'It’s not possible what you’re doing. You’re using both sides of your brain at the same time. And for you to sit there and do this while you’re talking to me is not possible.' He said, 'Bob, I want to do MRIs.'"


On supporting science journalism

If you're enjoying this article, consider supporting our award-winning journalism by subscribing. By purchasing a subscription you are helping to ensure the future of impactful stories about the discoveries and ideas shaping our world today.


You can read the rest of Scott Atkinson's fascinating profile of Milne at Mlive.com. And if you'd like to hear about Milne in podcast form, Radiolab featured him in 2011.

About Princess Ojiaku

Hey there! I'm a graduate student at the University of Wisconsin Madison in the Neuroscience and Public Policy program. I'm also a musician who played in two bands in North Carolina, one called Pink Flag and another called Deals. My personal passions are science, music, and cycling as transportation. I got into science as a kid while tagging along and watching my mom do experiments in her lab. I found that while I loved science, I didn't want to be alone in an ivory tower, crunching data that few others would understand. I also noticed that many other people thought science was this scary and incomprehensible entity of obscurity. When I realized that there were people working to make science fun and accessible to everyone, I knew that this was exactly what I wanted to do. The two things I find the most immensely interesting and continually impressing are music and neuroscience, so these are the topics that I'll focus on in my blog. Philosophy and politics are my second loves, so I might pop in an occasional post on these topics as well. Ultimately I am here to share things that give me wonder. I hope that reading Science with Moxie gives you a bit of that wonder too.

More by Princess Ojiaku