ADVERTISEMENT
  About the SA Blog Network













The Thoughtful Animal

The Thoughtful Animal


Exploring the evolution and architecture of the mind
The Thoughtful Animal Home

Rudolph Would Have Run Away From Santa

The views expressed are those of the author and are not necessarily those of Scientific American.


Email   PrintPrint



According to holiday lore, poor Rudolph was a victim of social exclusion because he was different from the rest of the reindeer. In a move that was lucky for nice (but not naughty) children everywhere, he was then approached by Santa, who asked him to guide the sleigh. Thereafter, according to traditional sources, all the reindeer loved him.

Like most bits of religious lore, however, the Rudolph story is rife with scientific errors. For one thing, it takes more than special attention by an authority figure for bullies to stop picking on those whom they perceive to be different – in fact, this often only serves to further isolate those who are victimized by bullying. But a bigger problem with the story is that reindeer – like most non-domesticated animals – are exceedingly unlikely to stick around long enough when a human approaches to have time to consider an offer like guiding a sleigh.

While cross-country skiing has been a human pastime in Norway and elsewhere for centuries, the activity has seen a recent increase in the last fifty years, owing to the continued construction of mountain cabins and ski lodges, and improved access to alpine areas due to the development of road and trail systems. With the increase in skiing also comes an increase in other snow activities, such as snowmobiling. In 2002, for example, there were 49,260 snowmobiles in operation in Norway.

This could be problematic for the 30,000 to 40,000 reindeer inhabiting the twenty-six defined “management areas” in Norway. During the harsh winter, reindeer typically reduce their activity and rely on a combination of stored fat and limited, nutrient-poor foods such as lichens in order to survive. The increasing human presence in reindeer habitats, therefore, could force the reindeer to use more energy than is optimal as they attempt to avoid human interaction. This could also reduce the time that reindeer can spend grazing. Taken together, human encroachment could have the compound effect of reducing the body weight of reindeer, and for females, their conception rate and age of first reproduction.

In an effort to understand how increasing tourism in remote parts of Norway could affect wild reindeer populations, researchers from the University of Norway compared the behavioral responses of reindeer (Rangifer tarandus tarandus) to humans on skis and to snowmobiles, in Setesdal-Ryfylke, in southern Norway (area 1 on the map, above right, click to enlarge).

Since the 1990s, the winter population in the study area has been stable at about 3000 reindeer, with approximately 800 calves born each year. On average, this comes out to one reindeer for every two square kilometers. Part of the reason for choosing this study area was the lack of large predators – this helps to ensure that reindeer responses to approaching skiers or snowmobiles aren’t affected by other nearby threats.

In order to collect their data, an observer approached a reindeer herd at a constant speed (4 km/hr for skiers, and 20 km/her for snowmobiles) until they had reached the original location of the herd.

For each incident, they recorded nine variables: the provocation method (ski or snowmobile), weather (sunny, cloudy, raining, snowing, foggy), wind speed, topography (level or hilly), activity of the reindeer prior to provocation (lying, foraging, moving, or a combination), herd size, herd composition, wind direction (relative to the reindeer), and the original position of the observer (relative to the reindeer).

In addition, they measured seven response variables:

  • (1) Start distance: distance between observer and the estimated center point of the herd at the beginning of the provocation.
  • (2) Sight distance: distance between the observer and the herd center point when more than 1 reindeer looked up in the observer direction.
  • (3) Fright distance: distance between the observer and the herd center point when the herd exhibited a fright response by grouping together.
  • (4) Flight distance: distance between the observer and the herd at the moment of flight.
  • (5) Escape distance: air distance from where reindeer took flight to where they resumed more relaxed behavior (i.e., grazing or lying).
  • (6) Total flight: air distance covered if the herd moved farther away from the observer after resuming more relaxed behavior the first time, and we determined that the movement was caused by the provocation.
  • (7) Total distance moved: total flight distance measured by total ground distance covered. The air and ground distance are equal if the reindeer escape in the same direction upon provocation. Any directional change during escape makes the ground distance longer.

In order to collect enough data, they repeated this each winter for three years.

The results were straightforward. Reindeer movement distances varied between 134 and 2,526 meters, with an average distance of 600 meters for snowmobiles and 970 meters for skiers. Compared to disturbances by skiers, reindeer became aware of snowmobiles (“sight distance”) at longer distances. However, their physical displacement was shorter for snowmobiles than for skiers (“total flight” and “total distance”). The researchers conclude that “reindeer were more easily disturbed by snowmobiles, but reacted stronger when provoked by skiers.”

Additional analyses indicated that “fright distance” was larger when approached from downhill than from uphill, and “escape distance” was farther when they had been lying rather than grazing.

It’s possible that the reindeer were able to notice the snowmobiles sooner due to the noise from their motors or the flashing from the headlights. Even still, skiers seem to disturb them more than snowmobiles, which is perhaps surprising. The researchers hypothesize that this could be due to confusing skiers for hunters. They write, “hunting is not allowed from motorized vehicles in Norway, and chasing and harassing wildlife is strictly forbidden. However, reindeer are hunted by humans on foot and probably do not discriminate between a hunter and a tourist.”

It should also be noted that these responses probably represent something like a maximum response to approaching skiers or snowmobiles for these reindeer, because the researchers always directly approached the center of the herd. In natural interactions, however, it is more likely for reindeer to be approached obliquely rather than directly.

What does all this mean for regulating the tourism industry in places such as Norway with wild reindeer? Wild reindeer in Norweigian mountains don’t generally have more than three human encounters per day during the busiest tourist seasons. By combining this with the data from their experiment, the researchers calculated that reindeer would add approximately 3.4% to their daily energy expenditure for three skier encounters, and 2.3% more for three snowmobile encounters. They note that this extra energy expenditure should be easily compensated for, as long as these encounters are limited to the 2-4 week-long tourist season.

This is good news, though the work is far from over: it is still possible that loss of access to optimal habitats due to avoidance of areas frequented by humans, combined with subsequent overgrazing of undisturbed habitats could still have negative implications for the health of reindeer herds.

The other caveat is that these numbers hold only as long as snow levels remain constant. This is because deeper snow makes moving through it more effortful, meaning that more energy would be expended by reindeer in flight from approaching humans. It is not clear how climate change could enter into this process: it is possible that increased snowfall due to climate change could make it impossible for reindeer to compensate for even three encounters per day with humans.

When most animals are approached by an unfamiliar other, they engage a stress response known colloquially as “fight or flight.” That is, the approach of a potential threat is alarming enough to the animal that it will retreat from the approaching human – when possible – or perhaps react with aggression. Santa never stood a chance when offering the sleigh to Rudolph.

Reimers, E., Eftestol, S., & Colman, J. (2003). Behavior Responses of Wild Reindeer to Direct Provocation by a Snowmobile or Skier The Journal of Wildlife Management, 67 (4) DOI: 10.2307/3802681

Reindeer photo, from a Beverly Hills storefront, copyright the author.

Jason G. Goldman About the Author: Dr. Jason G. Goldman received his Ph.D. in Developmental Psychology at the University of Southern California, where he studied the evolutionary and developmental origins of the mind in humans and non-human animals. Jason is also an editor at ScienceSeeker and Editor of Open Lab 2010. He lives in Los Angeles, CA. Follow on . Follow on Twitter @jgold85.

The views expressed are those of the author and are not necessarily those of Scientific American.





Rights & Permissions

Comments 9 Comments

Add Comment
  1. 1. Bonnie Nordby 9:07 am 12/26/2011

    What first came to mind was the relationship of reindeer and indiginous human populations in this area of the world. If the reindeer are impacted by snowmobiles than how much more would they be effected by large scale mining and oil extracting operations.
    I began to learn of the fight many indiginous peoples were waging to keep mining and oil extracting operations away from their lands. They see their vital resouces ie…reindeer being sacrificed for our first world hunger for more oil and products produced from mining. Look at your/my phone or computer right now. I wonder how many rare earth and other minerals are used in it’s manufacture? How much oil to produce, ship and support that piece of technology in your/my hand?
    Second I remember a book I didn’t get to read. “Why Zebra’s Don’t Get Ulcers?”. Maybe because they don’t keep asking questions. They just run.

    Link to this
  2. 2. JamesDavis 9:25 am 12/26/2011

    Jason, the flaw isn’t with the science, it’s from where you got the information. The reindeer at the North Pole is a different species than the reindeer in Norway. To prove my point: can the reindeer in Norway speak every language on Earth better than any human? Can the reindeer in Norway fly faster than the speed of light and stop on a dime on the roof of every house in the world in one night? …NO!, but the reindeer at the North Pole can. Are you starting to see the error of your research? Get with if man, you should’ve learned that when you were a child. Oh, how quickly we forget.

    Link to this
  3. 3. Vidhyacharan HR 10:56 am 12/26/2011

    The flaw isn’t with science. But with money and greediness! Good info.

    Link to this
  4. 4. jusher 2:43 am 12/27/2011

    Exactly. Rudolph is part of a special breed of reindeer. Ideas based on other reindeer are not applicable here. It would be like comparing a domestic dog with a wolf. They might be very close genetically, but they are quite difference from a practical point of view.

    Link to this
  5. 5. sablwolf 8:58 pm 12/27/2011

    Let me begin by saying that I have not read this article entirely, because you begin with two glaring errors: (1) The story of Rudolph is not a religious story–it was written as a department store promotion in the 1940′s, I believe, and is basically a children’s tale; (2) Reindeer are not wild animals–they may essentially be the same species as wild caribou, BUT they have been domesticated by various northern peoples for nearly 2000 years. I might read the rest of the article when you clean up your facts.Thank you.

    Link to this
  6. 6. jasongoldman 9:08 pm 12/27/2011

    Actually, reindeer are simply called “caribou” in North America. They’re effectively the same.

    Link to this
  7. 7. hungry doggy 4:49 pm 12/28/2011

    The story of Rudolf the Red Nose Reindeer is not a religious story. It was a children’s story written as a Christmas promotional campaign for Montgomery Wards.

    And as everyone knows, Santa’s reindeer are special. They have magic antlers that allow them to fly. And Santa can control time to make Christmas Eve last as long as he wants it to so that he has all the time he needs to visit every house. Don’t you people at SA know anything?

    Link to this
  8. 8. HubertB 11:25 am 12/30/2011

    That is interesting. Now that all Reindeer run away from humans the people who have lived for thousands of years herding Reindeer will no longer be able to make a living. What will they do?
    Please send me your money and I will figure out something.

    Link to this
  9. 9. Username4242 1:04 pm 12/30/2011

    In regard to the application of these data, I think that another thing to keep in mind is that the stress effects of human activity might be greater when the reindeer are already exposed to predation risk. It would be interesting to run a similar study in areas where predation is a factor, possibly coupling it with physiological data (stress hormone levels, etc.).

    Neat article.

    Link to this

Add a Comment
You must sign in or register as a ScientificAmerican.com member to submit a comment.

More from Scientific American

Scientific American Back To School

Back to School Sale!

12 Digital Issues + 4 Years of Archive Access just $19.99

Order Now >

X

Email this Article

X