About the SA Blog Network

Plugged In

Plugged In

More than wires - exploring the connections between energy, environment, and our lives
Plugged In HomeAboutContact

Did Congestion Charging Just Go Viral?

The views expressed are those of the author and are not necessarily those of Scientific American.

Email   PrintPrint

What is congestion charging?

Congestion charging or pricing is the practice of setting up cordon tolls around the city on a large-scale to charge entrants for entering during peak hours. Ideally, this is done in an automatic fashion with cameras registering your license plate and directly billing you. This is different from low emissions zones, which are specific zones that limit the type of vehicles that can enter, and when.

City-scale congestion charging is picking up steam as a policy tool to free cities from crippling traffic. Singapore led the way starting in 1975, and London, Milan, and Stockholm have since followed suit. In 2008, the former Mayor of New York City Michael Bloomberg led a valiant, but eventually doomed effort to install congestion charging around Manhattan. However, despite New York’s setback and otherwise sporadic progress, three news items make me wonder if congestion pricing is reaching a tipping point:

First, despite New York’s failed attempt, it looks as if a bottom-up plan could revive the city’s efforts. With crippling congestion and underfunded transit projects, New Yorkers are starting to rally to the cause. The key to success this time might be better consultation and more community engagement. So far so good.

Second, Stockholm’s at-first shaky congestion pricing plan is now considered an unobtrusive part of life. In fact, its popularity spurred Gothenburg to adopt it, and there are now proposals for all major Swedish cities to adopt the system [in Swedish].

Congestion charging point and payment information in Stockholm. Image courtesy of Transport Styrelsen.

Finally, we turn to the mother lode of traffic: China. Not only have Beijing and Shanghai studied the possibility of congestion charging for a while now, it appears that Beijing is going to institute it next year, using its many ring roads to its advantage.

While congestion charging did appear to sputter for a while, the recent activity together looks something akin to a revival. But what have we learned since its introduction? For one, geography matters. The reason Singapore, Stockholm, and London were able to institute the system was in part due to their restricted geography (rivers in large part), but that’s only part of the story. What Stockholm and New York both found out, was that you need to engage heavily with the community, in a (at least) one-time effort, which pays off over time. Finally, you need to make it crystal clear that the city is not just raising tolls or taking money to fill its coffers, but rather transferring it to new and improved public transit infrastructure to benefit the whole city.

If Beijing manages to use its ring roads to its advantage, and successfully pulls of a well-run congestion charge system, it might go viral. In a good way.

Tali Trigg About the Author: Energy and transport analyst who believes how you say it is as important as what you say. Opinions are his own. Follow on Twitter @talitrigg.

The views expressed are those of the author and are not necessarily those of Scientific American.

Rights & Permissions

Comments 2 Comments

Add Comment
  1. 1. Jerzy v. 3.0. 5:02 am 08/27/2014

    Congestion charging means rewarding city managers financially for having congested traffic. The worse congestion gets, the more money flows to the city budget. There is no incentive to remove congestion.

    Correct method to fight congestion is rewarding use of public transport, eg. by discounted season tickets. Of course, this needs city managers skilled in making efficent public transport, not just collecting money.

    I wonder if the Author personally used a car in a city with congestion charging? By my observations, cities experience one of two things: business as usual, and companies write off costs for employees, or companies, entertainment centres, cafes etc. move to the city outskirts, leaving slums in city centre. Traffic jams stay the same.

    Link to this
  2. 2. hkraznodar 4:07 pm 09/5/2014

    Well Jerzy, have you driven in a city with congestion charging? I notice that you don’t actually say that you ever have and your observations about other cities, aside from being anecdotal, mean next to nothing unless those cities have congestion charging.

    Link to this

Add a Comment
You must sign in or register as a member to submit a comment.

More from Scientific American

Email this Article