About the SA Blog Network



Opinion, arguments & analyses from the editors of Scientific American
Observations HomeAboutContact

Why Pygmies Are Short: New Evidence Surprises

The views expressed are those of the author and are not necessarily those of Scientific American.

Email   PrintPrint

Why pygmies are short

Sarah Tishkoff, center, with Pygmy women

Pygmy populations, scientists have speculated, may owe their abbreviated stature to natural selection pressures that allowed them to better adapt to dense tropical forests where heat is oppressive and food is scarce. “An outstanding question for many, many years among anthropologists and human geneticists has been what is the genetic basis of the short stature trait in Pygmy populations globally and in Africa in particular, says Sarah Tishkoff, a professor at the University of Pennsylvania, who is a leading expert on African population genetics. “There’s a good reason to think it’s adaptive because in fact in regions of dense tropical forests globally you often have these short-statured Pygmy groups.”

Tishkoff and colleagues have found an unexpected surprise in genetic evidence for Pygmy height, which reaches an average of 4 feet 11 inches in Pygmy men in Cameroon. They report in PLOS Genetics today on a set of genes that regulate immune and hormonal processes, and which only secondarily may be linked to height. Pygmies receive an intense assault from pathogens that flourish in the forest and that turn up routinely in their bush-meat diet: expected lifespan is less than 18 years. It may be that genes that protect against microbes may also hinder growth. Diminished stature could  be a byproduct of bolstering immune and metabolic defenses and not a direct adaptation to a hunter-gatherer lifestyle.

The study was  the most incisive to date looking at the genetics of height in Pygmies. Over many generations, pygmies have interbred with neighboring Bantu populations. The researchers scanned the genomes of 67 Pygmies and 58 Bantus for genetic markers, called single nucleotide polymorphisms, throughout the genome. They found that more Bantu ancestry translated into a taller individual, a confirmation that genes were involved with height differences.  They then looked more closely at the genomes of the two groups. A section of chromosome 3  differed greatly in Pygmies, a segment that also turned out through further analysis to show signs of being subject to selective pressures  and to be correlated with height.

In the area that stood out, a genetic variant in CISH, a gene known to regulate immune responses and linked to resistance to bacteremia, malaria and tuberculosis, attracted notice.  CISH also happens to inhibit production of human growth hormone. Mice genetically engineered to produce high levels of the CISH protein are undersized.

The research was designed to account for the exigencies of studying a small difficult-to-access population group. “For a typical complex trait  like height in Europeans, you need a very large sample size which was not  not feasible to collect for remote hunter-gatherer population,” Tishkoff says. “However, our approach that looks at sections of the genome that are targets of natural selection and then looks at associations of those regions with height gives us more statistical power in identifying regions of the genome that play a role in the short stature trait in Pygmies.”

Tishkoff says that other studies will undoubtedly turn up genes tied to height in Pygmies and natural selection may still be found to play a direct role in giving rise to short stature. Tishkoff worked closely with Joseph Jarvis, now at Coriell Institute for Medical Research,  and Alain Froment of the Musée de lHomme in Paris, who collected the Pygmy genetic samples.

Another gene that turned up on chromosome 3, DOCK3, has been associated with height in studies of European populations. But none of the hundreds of other height-related genes found in other groups were present in the Pygmy genetic analyses. ”It’s possible that Pygmies, due to strong selection pressures and their unique demographic history, may have a different genetic architecture of height,” Tishkoff says.

Africa has the most genetic diversity of any global region, the reason for Tishkoff’s research concentration. The study of height there illustrates how that diversity translates into differences in physical traits. Africa is also home to the tall, thin Dinka people in the upper Nile who tower about over Pygmies.


Source: Sarah Tishkoff



Gary Stix About the Author: Gary Stix, a senior editor, commissions, writes, and edits features, news articles and Web blogs for SCIENTIFIC AMERICAN. His area of coverage is neuroscience. He also has frequently been the issue or section editor for special issues or reports on topics ranging from nanotechnology to obesity. He has worked for more than 20 years at SCIENTIFIC AMERICAN, following three years as a science journalist at IEEE Spectrum, the flagship publication for the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers. He has an undergraduate degree in journalism from New York University. With his wife, Miriam Lacob, he wrote a general primer on technology called Who Gives a Gigabyte? Follow on Twitter @@gstix1.

The views expressed are those of the author and are not necessarily those of Scientific American.

Rights & Permissions

Comments 5 Comments

Add Comment
  1. 1. Dredd 4:59 pm 04/27/2012

    “It may be that genes that protect against microbes may also hinder growth.”

    Microbial DNA makes up the great bulk of the “human genome”, so that seems counter intuitive.

    Link to this
  2. 2. David Marjanović 7:31 am 04/29/2012

    Microbial DNA makes up the great bulk of the “human genome”, so that seems counter intuitive.


    Link to this
  3. 3. rugeirn 5:15 pm 04/30/2012

    According to the article, Pygmy life expectancy is less than 18 years. That’s barely enough time to reach puberty, far less than enough to raise a child to maturity. Why would we describe these genetic features as “adaptive?”

    Link to this
  4. 4. bucketofsquid 2:17 pm 05/3/2012

    The short life expectancy is likely unrelated to the height issue. Living in remote primitive areas is typically linked to very short lifespans, even among tall people.

    Link to this
  5. 5. upload70 11:06 am 10/6/2012

    no real surprise to find out it’s due to lack of hgh.

    Link to this

Add a Comment
You must sign in or register as a member to submit a comment.

More from Scientific American

Email this Article