About the SA Blog Network



Opinion, arguments & analyses from the editors of Scientific American
Observations HomeAboutContact

Can Extreme Resilience Be Taught?

The views expressed are those of the author and are not necessarily those of Scientific American.

Email   PrintPrint

You’re struggling up a hill halfway through a ten-mile race. Your breathing is ragged, and your footfalls seem heavy. You lurch toward the water station, grab a cup, and gulp it down. Back in the middle of the pack, you feel strengthened and pick up the pace.

Your decision to lope over to the water station relied on your interoceptive sense—the ability to sense your internal state. When you talk to your physician about a nagging pain or discomfort, you are also acting on information passing through your brain’s interoceptive system. Facing a major mental and physical challenge, however, requires you to do more. You need to match your internal sensations with an assessment of what the environment will demand of you. Do you need to slow down to summit the hill, or can you power through to the next water station?

A group from the University of California at San Diego and the Naval Health Research Center theorizes that the extra edge that allows certain people to perform particularly well in stressful situations may come not from a physiological advantage but from differences in the brain. To explore this question, they tested a group of Navy SEALs, adventure racers, and Marines, all of whom have learned to triumph over physical challenges without succumbing to stress. “Navy SEALs don’t all share a prototypical body type—they’re all different,” Nate Thom, a stress physiologist at the Naval Health Research Center, says. Nonetheless, they share a certain amount of resilience.

Specifically, they surmised that individuals who shine in tough circumstances may benefit from highly attuned interoception, which then informs the decision-making areas of the brain. Interoception is thought to rely heavily on the insula, a small brain area that plays an important role in self-awareness and emotional experiences.

To test their theory, the researchers first compared 11 Navy SEALs and 10 age- and education-matched healthy controls. Both groups were assessed on their ability to read happy and fearful faces. As the scientists had expected, the SEALs showed increased right insula activity across all emotional categories as compared with the healthy control subjects. They also were slightly slower to detect emotions, which may either be a fluke or may reflect the importance of accurately identifying an individual’s facial expression on the battlefield: it could be vital to detecting whether a setting is dangerous or safe.

In a second study, adventure racers—the type who sprint, paddle, and climb their way through wilderness endurance challenges—were subjected to the same emotion recognition task. They also underwent a breathing restriction task, which feels vaguely like suffocation and is intended to induce mild stress. The adventure racers also showed increased activity in the right insula in the emotion recognition task and less engagement of the region during the restriction test than controls, suggesting a lower stress response.

The results, presented in a poster session at the Society for Neuroscience, are the first two stages in a study that will compare SEALS with Marines and also assess the effectiveness of mindfulness training, which has been shown to improve interoceptive awareness. Staying in touch with both your insides and your outsides, it seems, may give you an added boost when you need it most.

Image courtesy of emmett.hume and flickr.

Rights & Permissions

Comments 2 Comments

Add Comment
  1. 1. Judybelmont 10:12 am 11/17/2011

    Yes – Resilience can be taught – As a psychotherapist and speaker, I teach life skills as resilience is not something people learn in school directly. There are specific life skills people can learn and all too often people see their stress coming from the outside and not the inside – It is our take on the stressors that give it meaning and by changing the way we let things outside of ourselves affect us, we can show the resilience that these Navy Seals did! Our self-awareness and self-empowerment is the key!
    Judy Belmont, Co-Author, The Swiss Cheese Theory of Life!

    Link to this
  2. 2. gmperkins 3:14 pm 11/17/2011

    Interesting test. Hard exercise is a component of both groups that showed increased right insula activity. So the question becomes can this be taught without hard exercise? (well, once more research is done, the groups were all small so this needed further experimental evalutation)

    There is also the matter of the brain ‘being lazy’. Our bodies are designed to try and work at a level that meets current survival needs. When it comes to exercise and sports, ect., we have to forcibly push ourselves to go past what our brains would normally allow. In children this seems to happen semi-naturally during play. The fun helps to push them to, say, play tag very hard and fast. In sports it seems to be about training and also attaining a mental state that allows one to function past normal limits, without having to expend willpower. Like in soccer, you just want to think ‘make that run’ but not have to think about pushing yourself to run hard, you just run hard automatically (this happens with enough practice and gameplay, as well as proper fitness). Then comes the next wall, the ability to push beyond safe levels of stress. To run hard enough that you might rip or tear muscles or even overstress bones/ligaments. This is different than pulls/tears when not properly warmed up or due to muscle imbalances. This is about being stoked on adrenelaine and for whatever reason deciding that beating the person to the ball or getting that extra yard or whatever, is vital to your ‘survival’. The brain will then allow muscles to overexert, for a brief time. Sometimes ‘time’ even slows down. You don’t always get hurt by this but it is always exhausting.

    Link to this

Add a Comment
You must sign in or register as a member to submit a comment.

More from Scientific American

Email this Article