ADVERTISEMENT
  About the SA Blog Network













Observations

Observations


Opinion, arguments & analyses from the editors of Scientific American
Observations HomeAboutContact

Sleep might help dieters shed more fat

The views expressed are those of the author and are not necessarily those of Scientific American.


Email   PrintPrint



woman sleeping, which might be key to helping body lose extra fatLaying up for a solid night’s sleep might not sound like the best recipe for weight loss, but loads of research has pointed to the importance of sufficient shut-eye to losing weight. And a small new study shows that not getting enough sleep might severely cut into people’s ability to lose extra fat. 

Researchers found that if dieters got a full night’s rest, they more than doubled the amount of weight lost from fat reserves. So even though subjects lost about as much weight when they were sleep deprived as when they were well-rested, only about a quarter of the weight lost during the short sleep period was from fat. Tired-eyed dieters also reported feeling hungrier than they did when they had gotten enough sleep. Results of the study were published online October 4 in Annals of Internal Medicine.

"Cutting back on sleep, a behavior that is ubiquitous in modern society, appears to compromise efforts to lose fat," Plamen Penev, an assistant professor of medicine at the University of Chicago and study co-author, said in a prepared statement. Study subjects lost about 55 percent more fat when they got ample sleep at night.

For the study, 10 overweight volunteers (ages 35 to 49 with a mean body-mass index of 27.4 kilograms) started a personalized diet plan that reduced calories (to an average of about 1,450 per day) but maintained a sedentary lifestyle. For two weeks, subjects reported to the lab to spend 8.5 hours a night in bed (with an average sleep time of about seven hours and 25 minutes), and during a second two-week period—either three months before or after the 8.5-hour nights—the same volunteers were allowed only 5.5 hours a night in bed (with an average sleep time of five hours and 14 minutes).

During both study sessions, the subjects lost about three kilograms each. Nearly half of that (1.4 kg) was from fat when the volunteers were sleeping long, but less than a fifth (0.6 kg) of the lost weight was from fat when they got less than six hours of sleep. The rest of the weight was fat-free body mass, which includes other components such as water or muscle, and is generally not the target of those seeking to lose weight.

Food cravings and metabolism are controlled in part by hormones, such as ghrelin, which stimulates hunger and lowers energy use. And when the study subjects were getting less than six hours of sleep a night, their ghrelin levels rose from 75 nanograms per liter to 84 ng per liter. Levels remained steady when subjects got plenty of rest. The volunteers were on the same tightly controlled low-calorie diet during both phases of the study, and the weight- and fat-loss difference between adequate sleep and too little sleep might otherwise be even more pronounced, the researchers behind the study speculated.

So despite any extra calories a person might burn while burning the midnight oil, losing sleep is hardly the best way to lose fat, this study suggests. "If your goal is to lose fat, skipping sleep is like poking sticks in your bicycle wheels," Penev said. "One should not ignore the way they sleep when going on a diet." Plenty of other research also suggests that getting enough sleep is also crucial for good long-term health in general.

Image courtesy of iStockphoto/Mari





Rights & Permissions

Comments 9 Comments

Add Comment
  1. 1. koala_man 2:32 am 10/5/2010

    This is very interesting research! The amount of weight lost — 3kg in two weeks — is about twice the rate conventionally recommended. Would a more gentle rate of weight loss have evened the results significantly?

    PS: BMI is not measured in kilograms, but in kilograms per meter squared.

    Link to this
  2. 2. Lascap 1:32 pm 10/5/2010

    Interesting study, but the author clearly doesn’t even know what BMI is, or what its units are. Where does Scientific American find these people?

    Link to this
  3. 3. leoluca criscione 2:25 pm 10/5/2010

    The differences might be statistically significant, but biologically irrelevant!
    The explanation is very simple: Either you sleep or you eat! The more you sleep, the less time you have to eat!
    This publication goes under the chapter: Science ‘feeds’ confusion… as described in more details in the forthcoming (end of October) book: Eating healthy and dying obese!
    Sleepy regards from Switzerland
    Leoluca Criscione, Obesity scientist

    Link to this
  4. 4. koala_man 6:27 am 10/7/2010

    The study used personalized diet plans with fixed amounts of calories, followed twice by each of the participants under varying amounts of sleep.

    Please find a more suitable medium to advertise your upcoming book, and kindly change your title to "Obesity pseudo-scientist" to make it easier to distinguish you from those doing more rigorous research for peer reviewed publication.

    Link to this
  5. 5. GeorgeMHarrison 5:19 am 01/1/2011

    [url=http://www.dietpromises.com]diet plans[/url]

    Link to this
  6. 6. GeorgeMHarrison 5:21 am 01/1/2011

    Exercise just prior to bedtime. Even if you exercise during the day can also help you sleep better during the night. Intercourse is a great way to exercise prior to falling asleep for the night. It’s a great stress reliever too. Burn more fat AND become stree-free? That’s awesome if you ask me!

    Vist my website for other articles http://www.dietpromises.com/

    Link to this
  7. 7. bioslifeslim 1:57 am 03/17/2011

    Thousands have shown that they’ve lost fat simply by adding <a href="http://www.bioslifeslim.com/titusinternational/">Bios Life Slim</a> to their diet.

    Link to this
  8. 8. bioslifeslim 1:58 am 03/17/2011

    Thousands have shown that they’ve lost fat simply by adding <a href="http://www.bioslifeslim.com/titusinternational/">Bios Life Slim</a> to their diet.

    Link to this
  9. 9. tejul 1:55 pm 03/20/2013

    Sleeping actually is a good idea! While you sleep, your body rests, but your muscles still burn energy. It is said that if you want to get a good night sleep than you must go to bed prior to midnight. Every hour prior to midnight counts as two hours. When it comes to weight loss, having enough sleep is not enough ofcourse. You must adapt your lifestyle. Do a lot of sports, eat healthy, avoid bad food. Consume a lot of omega 3. Here is a list of omega 3 foods to help you eat more healthy.
    Staying in shape is great!
    Regards, Tej

    Link to this

Add a Comment
You must sign in or register as a ScientificAmerican.com member to submit a comment.

More from Scientific American

Scientific American Holiday Sale

Give a Gift &
Get a Gift - Free!

Give a 1 year subscription as low as $14.99

Subscribe Now! >

X

Email this Article

X