About the SA Blog Network



Opinion, arguments & analyses from the editors of Scientific American
Observations HomeAboutContact

Happy or sad, emotions persisted beyond remembering an event in people with amnesia

The views expressed are those of the author and are not necessarily those of Scientific American.

Email   PrintPrint

emotion memory amnesia film alzheimer'sHow long does a sad movie leave you feeling blue? Remembering something sad can trigger emotions that persist long after the event itself has passed. But people with impaired memories seem to retain the emotion long after they have forgotten the emotionally charged event itself—longer, in fact, than people who can recall the incident well—according to a new study.

The findings, published online April 12 in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, are some of the first to investigate the persistence of emotion after memory of the triggering incident has faded and reveal a need for more research about how people with faulty memories, such as the growing number of people with Alzheimer’s disease, process and conserve emotions. 

Researchers at the University of Iowa worked with five patients who had severe amnesia due to damage in the hippocampus (which is thought to play a role in creating lasting memories), resulting in a condition that might be comparable to Alzheimer’s and other forms of dementia. The team surveyed the patients’ emotional states before, right after and 20 to 30 minutes after showing them a series of film clips of sad scenes (including a funeral in Steel Magnolias and dementia as portrayed in The Notebook) one day and happy scenes (such as practical jokes from the show America’s Funniest Home Videos and a humorously faked orgasm in When Harry Met Sally) on another day.

The researchers, led by Justin Feinstein of Iowa’s departments of Neurology and Psychology, found that even after memory tests (given five to 10 minutes after the film clips ended), the amnesic subjects remembered little—if any—of the details of what they had just seen, but retained the overall emotion for 20 to 30 minutes afterward. Although the subject group was small, the researchers concluded that the "findings provide direct evidence that a feeling of emotion can endure beyond the conscious recollection for the events that initially triggered the emotion," they reported.

Furthermore, when comparing the amnesic patients to normal controls who underwent the same viewing and questioning, the researchers found that the memory-impaired individuals felt happy about as long as their normal counterparts, but the amnesic patients’ sadness persisted longer.

Feinstein and his colleagues noted that these findings challenge the idea that by minimizing a specific memory of past trauma, associated sadness will also decrease. One amnesic patient in particular explained that the sources of happy feelings were usually also mysterious, but she didn’t feel the need to remember exactly what triggered them. Sad emotions, on the other hand, left her mentally searching for a cause, thereby, perhaps extending the duration of the feeling in comparison with a person who can remember what caused the sadness. "Erasing memories may have the paradoxical effect of actually prolonging (rather than alleviating) feelings of distress," the researchers explained.

The results might also provide more scientific "reasons for treating amnesic patients with respect and dignity," the researchers concluded. "A simple visit or telephone call…might have a lingering positive on a patient’s affective state even though the patient may quickly forget the visit or phone call," they noted. Similarly, "routine neglect from staff at nursing homes may leave the patient feeling sad, frustrated and lonely" for extended periods as they try to figure out why they feel that way.

Image courtesy of iStockphoto/CREATISTA

Rights & Permissions

Comments 3 Comments

Add Comment
  1. 1. sunnystrobe 8:59 am 04/13/2010

    Emotions lingering on , long after long-forgotten events that triggered them? Old hat! It’ s the stuff that dreams are made on; Wordsworth called this phenomenon : ‘Emotion recollected in tranquillity’.
    Emotions are clearly stored in a much more primeval part of the brain, whereas the actual situations that instigated them are registered in a rather recently evolved temporal section, which is more prone to deteriorate over a human life time, due to Alzheimer’s, or alcoholism, etc.
    Schizophrenia, interestingly, is also a disease where the wiring between the emotional and the rational thinking parts of the human brain appears to come apart; perhaps this is the price we have to pay for our evolutionary journey into becoming homo sapiens?

    Link to this
  2. 2. gjgower 8:51 pm 04/15/2010

    Have you seen the YouTube where the dog repeatedly thinks his hind foot is a marauder trying to steal his food? Clearly a neurological disorder or something similar, we would say. But strange animal behaviors abound, and quite probably represent disturbances of brain and endocrine function as do so many "mental illnesses" of humans.

    Link to this
  3. 3. mo98 9:45 pm 04/15/2010

    Another group to study could be neglected stroke victims of past repute who most probably retain abilities to deprogram themselves of their illnesses just by allowing others time to let them grieve to an audience. Seemingly forgotten positive emotions and related memories of some magnitude return not long thereafter. The results are most rewarding if sibling rivalries don’t diminish the purpose of such encounters with superficial skepticism. Applied amateur mental health practice every few weeks apart while visiting elders teaches us more about the science of humanity and aging as well.

    Link to this

Add a Comment
You must sign in or register as a member to submit a comment.

More from Scientific American

Email this Article