About the SA Blog Network



Opinion, arguments & analyses from the editors of Scientific American
Observations HomeAboutContact

Volcanoes killed with global warming, 200 million years ago

The views expressed are those of the author and are not necessarily those of Scientific American.

Email   PrintPrint

north-american-basaltWhen Pangaea finally broke up, some 200 million years ago, the result was a lot of heat. Specifically, volcanism, as enormous flows of basalt burst to the surface, ultimately covering more than nine million square kilometers. It wasn’t just the death of a supercontinent; it was also one of Earth’s five major extinction events—and the one that paved the way for the dinosaurs.

Now scientists have linked this great volcanism to catastrophic climate change via an analysis of carbon isotopes in wood and soil preserved in rocks. In short, geologist Jessica Whiteside of Brown University and her colleagues show in a paper published March 22 in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences that the extinction event at the end of the Triassic occurred at the same time as carbon dioxide levels jumped and shell-forming animals in the ocean suddenly had a much harder time forming their homes thanks to an eruption that lasted for more than 500,000 years.

Looking at the geologic record, Whiteside and her colleagues record a drop in carbon 13 roughly 200 million years ago. That suggests more of the lighter isotope of carbon (C-12) had suddenly become available, since plants prefer to use it, which in turn suggests soaring levels of CO2 in the atmosphere. Those levels persisted for at least 20,000 years, followed by another at least 20,000-year period when plants were forced to cope with higher C-13 levels. Records found in rocks that were underwater all those years ago show a similar pattern. All in all, it adds up to "strong direct evidence by direct superposition that the eruption of a giant flood basalt province could cause a climatic catastrophe resulting in a major mass extinction."

But mysteries remain about what specifically caused the jump in CO2 levels. As the scientists write, "it is unlikely that [the changes in carbon isotope levels] was generated by mantle CO2 alone." Other variables could include a massive burp of methane from the sea bottom that had been trapped in ice (clathrates) or the increasing levels of sulfuric acid as a result of all the volcanism. Nor can the scientists "exclude a role for a bolide impact as a killing mechanism" though no asteroid crater has been found to date.

It does not paint a pretty picture of what happens when CO2 levels rise. Terrestrial and marine life, such as tetrapods and pollinating plants, dwindled as a result of the sudden rise in CO2 levels in the atmosphere, with attendant ocean acidification. It remains to be seen who might benefit from today’s ongoing sixth extinction and its related climate change, as theropod dinosaurs benefited from the end-Triassic extinction. But it usually isn’t the dominant life forms on the planet at the time.

Image: North Mountain basalt of the Central Atlantic Magmatic Province (brown) resting above the level of the end-Triassic extinction event (in white layer), in turn, resting on red shallow lake deposits at Red Head, Five Island Provincial Park, Nova Scotia, Canada. Photo is by Jessica H. Whiteside.

Rights & Permissions

Comments 5 Comments

Add Comment
  1. 1. RDH 10:16 am 03/23/2010

    We finally know what killed off the dinosaurs.

    Link to this
  2. 2. Bill Crofut 7:30 pm 03/23/2010

    Here’s an interesting twist on global warming:

    "…[o]ne of the reasons paleontologists today believe one of the reasons dinosaurs grew so large, was that they werent cold-blooded like todays lizards; they were lukewarm-blooded….But another reason for their size may have been the sweltering oxygen-rich environment that came to dominate the dinosaur era; an environment triggered by volcanism….It was global warming gone wild; CO2 levels increased over 500 percent and temperatures soared. In
    the greenhouse conditions this created, huge tropical forests spread over many of the continents….Many scientists believe that evolving for millions of years, in this warm, oxygen-rich world, allowed the lukewarm-blooded dinosaurs to reach their enormous sizes. Huge dinosaurs may have been a
    biological response to a volcanically over-active planet….65 million years ago. The planet was lush. Vegetation was thick on the surface. Living things were prospering like never before."

    [2007. How the Earth was Made, DVD. London: Pioneer Productions for the History Channel, 55 min., ff., 1 hr., 3

    Link to this
  3. 3. Earthling 3:28 pm 03/25/2010

    The Gravity Theory of Mass Extinction would explain the survival of the dinosaurs and the demise of the crurotarsans as being the result of a rapid surface gravitation increase at the end-Triassic. Crurotarsans, with their splayed-leg gait, would have been at a distinct disadvantage to the straight-legged dinosaurs. No need for a "blind luck" explanation here. The surface gravitational increase was a result of the Earth’s core’s shift.

    Link to this
  4. 4. Earthling 3:39 pm 03/25/2010

    Read the Gravity Theory of Mass Extinction for an explanation of why the dinosaurs survived and the crurotarsans did not. No "blind luck" explanation is needed.

    Link to this
  5. 5. jtdwyer 12:51 am 03/28/2010

    Bill Crofut – Nice reference. I don’t have the specific reference data, but similarly, many if not all dinosaurs had an air-sac respiratory system, much like birds. It’s efficient at extracting oxygen from the atmosphere, as it does not mix incoming air and outgoing waste gases. Either or both provide improved respiration compared to lungs, allowing some birds to fly for many hours at high altitude with low oxygen and no rest periods! The dinosaurs likely have growth enabling high performance respiration even without high oxygen levels.

    Link to this

Add a Comment
You must sign in or register as a member to submit a comment.

More from Scientific American

Email this Article