ADVERTISEMENT
  About the SA Blog Network













Molecules to Medicine

Molecules to Medicine


Demystifying drug development, clinical research, medicine, and the role ethics plays
Molecules to Medicine Home

H1N-What? Wading Through the Alphabet Soup of Flu Names

The views expressed are those of the author and are not necessarily those of Scientific American.


Email   PrintPrint



Flu...the Coop

Muddled about all the new flu viruses?

It’s hard to keep up with the changing names in the news. H1Nwhat? Bird flu. Pig flu. MERS. SARS. Here is a quick overview of this dizzying, dyslexia inducing array, with what you need to worry about, even if some aren’t yet in your backyard.

Acronym soup

I explained a bit about regular, or seasonal flu in a recent post. There are three main types of flu, A, B, and C, named after core proteins. Most of the seasonal flu outbreaks each year are from influenza A. Influenza B strikes every 2-4 years, and is a less serious problem. C is milder and hasn’t caused epidemics.

The different strains of influenza A are named for surface proteins, HA (hemagglutinin) and NA (neuraminidase). Three subtypes of H (H1, H2, H3) and two of NA (N1 and N2) generally cause the annual epidemics.  This year’s strain, pH1N1, caused a large worldwide outbreak in 2009, infecting an estimated 24% of the world’s population (and almost half of kids age 5-19) and killing ~200,000. In contrast, the 1918 H1N1 pandemic killed 50 million.

Again, the best illustration I’ve seen for the relationship between different flu strains in people and animals is that by David McCandless.

"Influ-venn-za"

Reassortment occurs when two different flu strains infect a cell simultaneously, and RNA from each recombine, forming a new combination with different surface proteins and to which there is little immunity. Such new strains produced by reassortment are often seen initially in China and Southeast Asia because people, birds, and pigs live in close, often crowded conditions.

There have been four pandemics (worldwide epidemics) in past 100 years:

1918  H1N1, from seasonal human and avian (bird) flu

1957  H2N2, from human and avian reassortment

1968  H3N2 human and avian components

2009  novel H1N1 contains genes from a combination of human, swine, and avian reassortment.

When these viruses cross different species, that creates conditions ripe for another pandemic, as people lack immunity to these new strains. So what are the new strains that are emerging from animals, threatening explosive epidemics?

 

Comparison of Flu Strains - H1NWhat?

To help me keep these confusing sound-alikes straight, I made a table, like I have done for studying seemingly forever. (Click to enlarge the image). These are ordered by my worry level.
Further details follow, below.

 

To market to market to find a fat pig...

 

H1N1

The 1918 H1N1 flu was originally from an avian strain that adapted to be able to infect people. While initially thought to have originated in battle-torn Europe, new evidence suggests the “Spanish” flu actually originated in China. Because there was no pre-existing immunity, this virus fueled a widespread pandemic and vast number of deaths. This is why there is concern that H5N1 will similarly make the jump from birds to people.

The H1N1 that emerged in 2009 is now designated as “novel H1N1” or pH1N1, to identify it as being different from the human origin H1N1. The pH1N1 has genetic material from birds and swine (and was previously called “swine flu”).

Age and pre-morbid health of patients who died from A/H1N1

The most striking difference between H1N1 and the seasonal flu is that typically in seasonal flu, the elderly are the group dying. In 2009, however, deaths were conspicuously in young adults, especially in pregnant women, and that pattern appears to be recurring this year. One of the theories about the high death rate in young adults is that this is due to a “cytokine storm,” where a robust immune system produces an excessive inflammatory response to the infection, damaging the lungs and leading to death. This is believed to have caused many of the deaths in 1918. And many elderly appear to have some protective cross-immunity from previous infections, resulting in their lower death rate in the 2009 outbreak. Curiously, with H1N1, mortality has been highest in pregnancy, obesity, young adults, and indigenous peoples.

The incubation period is generally 1.5-3 days, but can go up to 7 days. Viral shedding begins before symptoms, so people can spread infection before they know they are ill. Shedding typically lasts 5-7 days, but may be much longer, especially in immunocompromised people.

One of the problems with pH1N1 is that the rapid diagnostic tests available are very inaccurate, often missing the flu. Specimens from suspected patients then have to be sent to a CDC-affiliated lab for RT-PCR (reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction) rather than being done locally. Treatment decisions therefore have to be made based on clinical symptoms and epidemiology.

Treatment options are limited, largely due to the rapid emergence of resistance to oseltamivir (Tamiflu).

There is a recent disturbing article from Matt Memoli showing that patients who are immunocompromised may initially show fewer symptoms than normal hosts, though they have a much higher respiratory failure and death rate. They also can shed virus for prolonged periods—a mean of 19 days. A few shed virus for months, some multi-resistant, meaning these patients could become an important source for spreading drug resistant strains throughout a community.

H3N2

H3N2 is a seasonal variant of influenza A, and is one of the strains used in the flu vaccine. The problem again comes from a reassortant strain, H3N2v, which is a combination of swine flu and pandemic H1N1, which emerged in 2012.

Infections with H3N2v have been seen mostly in children less than 10 years old, who have no protective immunity, and are associated with exposure to pigs at agricultural fairs. Curiously, while cases have been reported globally, they are more prominent in the Americas. There have only been 300+ cases reported so far. Symptoms are typical flu-like, with fever, cough, runny nose, and myalgias (muscle aches), and mortality is low, as with seasonal flu (<1%).

H7N9 and other new Chinese strains

First reported in 1999, infections with H9N2 have been seen mostly in China, and associated with poultry exposure. There have been less than 20 cases to date, generally mild, and more often in younger children. H9N2 can also infect cats and dogs, who then can further serve as hosts, spreading infection.

There is evidence that H9N2 coexists with H7N9 in live poultry markets, raising heightened concern that reassortment will occur, resulting in a more virulent strain.

Just last month, another new influenza A was identified in China. The first H10N8 infection was found in a 73 year old, immunocompromised woman.

H7N9 Geographic distribution

 

H7N9, another bird flu first reported in China in March, 2013, has produced only mild illness in poultry, making surveillance and detection more difficult. About 220 people have been infected to date, but they have been much more ill than the other strains discussed. Unlike the other strains, which primarily cause illness in the young, H7N9 affects older adults (mean 60 yo), and mostly (70%) men. It is believed to be transmitted through live poultry markets; more than 75% of affected patients had had contact with domestic poultry. Given this, widespread culling of poultry has begun in some areas, as well as closures of live markets. There have been few family clusters and only 2 cases in health care workers (HCW), suggesting little person-to-person transmission.

But H7N9 causes severe pneumonia, ARDS, multi-organ failure, and has a fatality rate of 25-33%. The high death rate appears linked to high cytokine levels. Interestingly, there also appears to be a genetic predisposition to the worse illness. [Widely varying death rates were seen in the 2009 H1N1 pandemic as well, with particularly high mortality in Mexico].

Projected growth in H7N9

A new study shows that H7N9 can be transmitted to songbirds—finches and parakeets, as well as to sparrows—via water troughs. Because domesticated chickens and game birds also interact with the songbirds, this may facilitate interspecies spread. Song birds are quite popular as pets in China, particularly among elderly men, which might help explain the different epidemiologic pattern of illness.

H5N1, aka Bird flu

Spreading joy wherever we go...Cambodia

Here things start to get even more interesting and a lot more worrisome. This avian flu was first detected in 1997 in Hong Kong. Since 2003, there have been epidemics in infected birds, with spread of the infection from Asia to Europe by migrating birds. In China and Southeast Asia, millions of birds have been killed in an attempt to quell outbreaks.

While only ~650 cases have been reported from 16 countries so far, this strain, like H7N9, causes respiratory failure, and 60% of victims died. Only H5N1 is again killing a younger population, with 79% of deaths occurring in those under 30. Earlier in January, the first case of H5N1 was reported in North America, in a young woman who died after a 3-week visit to Beijing, China. She reportedly had no contact with live markets or farms. Also atypically, she died of meningoencephalitis, rather than pneumonia.

Comparsion of Age Groups, H5N1 H7N9

While there have been outbreaks of highly pathogenic H5N1 in poultry and wild birds in India, there have been no human reports yet. A new study looking at antibodies to H5 and H7 in 466 high risk poultry workers in Pune, India found zero antibodies to either strain. This suggests that huge populations there are at risk for outbreaks from these more pathogenic strains.

H5N1 outbreaks have raised two other particular issues. The first is that of “dual-use research of concern”(DURC), which is research that could be misused for harm. With H5N1, the question came to a head over whether data regarding transmission of a mutated H5N1 virus to ferrets or people should be prohibited from publication as a national security issue.

H5N1 Distribution

The other issue relates to global economic disparities. Indonesia, the country most affected by H5N1, decided to stop sending viral isolates to WHO in 2007, seriously hampering efforts to study the newly emerging virus. Indonesia’s argument was that the samples they freely provided would be exploited by wealthy countries to develop a vaccine that would be too costly for developing countries. Similarly, concerns have also justifiably been raised that, in the event of a pandemic, vaccines or medicines would be stockpiled by wealthy countries and not be shared with those in need. A pact was reached in 2011, stipulating that at least 10% of antivirals and vaccines would be reserved for WHO donations and tiered pricing.

Implications

So why worry about these new flu strains?

A big immediate source of concern is that there are relatively novel flu strains circulating in China, ready to wantonly exchange genetic information, producing a new, lethal flu, to which people have no immunity. Doomsday scenarios have this being spread throughout the world by migrating birds as well as people’s travel.

There are problems with surveillance and with responses to such threats. For example, last fall’s short-sighted Congressional budget slowdown caused the CDC to have to stop monitoring for flu. Similarly, NIH’s funding for influenza research was cut 7% in 2012.

Lack of rapid, accurate diagnostic tests fuels the overuse of antibiotics, particularly levofloxacin (Levaquin), a major contributor to the rise in antibiotic resistance, MRSA, and C. difficile infections. Antibiotics are not necessary or helpful for viral infections!

Vaccine production often falls short and most of the supply has been produced in wealthy countries, causing both logistical problems in fulfilling needs, as well as ethical concerns over the disparities in access.

I’ll have more on vaccine development and on the other threatening respiratory viruses in an upcoming post.

Conclusion

It appears that we have been fortunate that no influenza to rival the deadly 1918 “Spanish flu” has yet appeared.  Given the pool of viruses circulating in birds, people and other mammals, especially in China, the ease with which viruses reassort themselves, and the ease of transmission by migratory birds and travelers, many knowledgeable people are wondering just how long our good fortune can last.

Suggested reading/resources for this rapidly changing news:

CIDRAP, Center for Infectious Disease Research and Policy

Flutrackers

Crawford Killian Crof’s blog

Michael Costen Avian Flu Diary

and on Twitter: Helen Branswell, Laurie Garrett, Crawford Killian

Credits:

H1N1 age distribution -  BMJ 2009;339:b5213

Influ-venn-za by David McCandless

H7N9 map, projected growth graph, and age distribution courtesy Laidback Al, Novel Infectious Diseases

Photos by Judy Stone CC BY-NC-SA 3.0

“Molecules to Medicine” banner © Michele Banks

Judy Stone About the Author: Judy Stone, MD is an infectious disease specialist, experienced in conducting clinical research. She is the author of Conducting Clinical Research, the essential guide to the topic. She survived 25 years in solo practice in rural Cumberland, Maryland, and is now broadening her horizons. She particularly loves writing about ethical issues, and tilting at windmills in her advocacy for social justice. As part of her overall desire to save the world when she grows up, she has become especially interested in neglected tropical diseases. When not slaving over hot patients, she can be found playing with photography, friends’ dogs, or in her garden. Follow on Twitter @drjudystone or on her website. Follow on Twitter @drjudystone.

The views expressed are those of the author and are not necessarily those of Scientific American.





Rights & Permissions

Comments 3 Comments

Add Comment
  1. 1. EHendrick 12:32 pm 01/30/2014

    The graphic shows that the 1918 outbreak is from swine flu (Spanish Flu) but the article states it was avian flu and seasonal human…?
    Can you please clarify?

    Link to this
  2. 2. reginam 3:00 pm 01/31/2014

    Interesting about the impact of budget cutbacks on flu surveillance. I wonder if the CDC still has so-called “flu sentinels” working in the 50 states. It was always my understanding that these primary care docs helped establish early patterns of flu activity every season, though maybe more modern methods are used today. In any case, calculating annual flu estimates has always been a bit of a mystery to me .. never quite sure how those numbers were arrived at.

    Link to this
  3. 3. Judy Stone in reply to Judy Stone 8:55 pm 01/31/2014

    I’m not sure I totally understand your question, but I’ll try. One issue is that different sources say different things, and that is probably the difference you are seeing between the graphic I used and the text.

    re 1918 flu: “Cloning and sequencing of all eight virus genes (Taubenberger et al. 2005) revealed that these viruses are closely related to avian influenza viruses with regard to their coding sequence; however, the identity of the exact precursor of the pandemic strain still remained unclear.”

    And see if this clarifies: “The eight influenza genes can be thought of as players on a team: Certain combinations of players may arise through chance and endow the virus with new abilities, such as the ability to infect a new type of host,” says Dr. Morens, Senior Advisor to the NIAID Director. That is likely what happened to spark the 1918 pandemic, he adds. Scientists have shown that the founding virus was an avian-like virus. The virus had a novel set of eight genes and—through still-unknown mechanisms—gained the ability to infect people and spread readily from person to person.

    Not only did the 1918 H1N1 virus set off an explosive pandemic in which tens of millions died, during the pandemic the virus was transmitted from humans to pigs, where—as it does in people—it continues to evolve to this day. “Ever since 1918, this tenacious virus has drawn on a bag of evolutionary tricks to survive in one form or another…and to spawn a host of novel progeny viruses with novel gene constellations, through the periodic importation or exportation of viral genes,” write the NIAID authors.”

    Hence my comment in the text: 1918 H1N1 flu was originally from an avian strain
    The 2009 pH1N1 has reassorted genetic material from both birds and swine

    Hope that helps. If not, I can try again.

    Link to this

Add a Comment
You must sign in or register as a ScientificAmerican.com member to submit a comment.

More from Scientific American

Scientific American Special Universe

Get the latest Special Collector's edition

Secrets of the Universe: Past, Present, Future

Order Now >

X

Email this Article

X