ADVERTISEMENT
  About the SA Blog Network













MIND Guest Blog

MIND Guest Blog


Commentary invited by editors of Scientific American Mind
MIND Guest Blog HomeAboutContact

The Fat-Fueled Brain: Unnatural or Advantageous?

The views expressed are those of the author and are not necessarily those of Scientific American.


Email   PrintPrint



Disclaimer: First things first. Please note that I am in no way endorsing nutritional ketosis as a supplement to, or a replacement for medication. As you’ll see below, data exploring the potential neuroprotective effects of ketosis are still scarce, and we don’t yet know the side effects of a long-term ketogenic diet. This post talks about the SCIENCE behind ketosis, and is not meant in any way as medical advice.

It’s not bacon; it’s therapy! Source: Renée S. Suen on Flickr.

It’s not bacon; it’s therapy! Source: Renée S. Suen on Flickr.

The ketogenic diet is a nutritionist’s nightmare. High in saturated fat and VERY low in carbohydrates, “keto” is adopted by a growing population to paradoxically promote weight loss and mental well-being. Drinking coffee with butter? Eating a block of cream cheese? Little to no fruit? To the uninitiated, keto defies all common sense, inviting skeptics to wave it off as an unnatural “bacon-and-steak” fad diet.

Yet versions of the ketogenic diet have been used to successfully treat drug-resistant epilepsy in children since the 1920s – potentially even back in the biblical ages. Emerging evidence from animal models and clinical trials suggest keto may be therapeutically used in many other neurological disorders, including head ache, neurodegenerative diseases, sleep disorders, bipolar disorder, autism and brain cancer. With no apparent side effects.

Sound too good to be true? I feel ya! Where are these neuroprotective effects coming from? What’s going on in the brain on a ketogenic diet?

Ketosis in a nutshell

In essence, a ketogenic diet mimics starvation, allowing the body to go into a metabolic state called ketosis (key-tow-sis). Normally, human bodies are sugar-driven machines: ingested carbohydrates are broken down into glucose, which is mainly transported and used as energy or stored as glycogen in liver and muscle tissue. When deprived of dietary carbohydrates (usually below 50g/day), the liver becomes the sole provider of glucose to feed your hungry organs – especially the brain, a particularly greedy entity accounting for ~20% of total energy expenditure. The brain cannot DIRECTLY use fat for energy. Once liver glycogen is depleted, without a backup energy source, humanity would’ve long disappeared in the eons of evolution.

The backup is ketone bodies that the liver derives primarily from fatty acids in your diet or body fat. These ketones – β-hydroxybutyrate (BHB), acetoacetate and acetone – are released into the bloodstream, taken up by the brain and other organs, shuttled into the “energy factory” mitochondria and used up as fuel. Excess BHB and acetoacetate are excreted from urine, while acetone, due to its volatile nature, is breathed out (hence the characteristically sweet “keto breath”). Meanwhile, blood glucose remains physiologically normal due to glucose derived from certain amino acids and the breakdown of fatty acids – voila, low blood sugar avoided!

Carbohydrate restriction induces the pancreas to "tell" fat cells to release fatty acids, which get taken up by the liver and converted into ketones and released into blood. Once taken up by the brain, ketones enter the TCA cycle to generate energy. Source: Shelly Fan.

Carbohydrate restriction induces the pancreas to "tell" fat cells to release fatty acids, which get taken up by the liver and converted into ketones and released into blood. Once taken up by the brain, ketones enter the TCA cycle to generate energy. Source: Shelly Fan. (click to see large)

Brain on ketones: Energetics, Oxidation and Inflammation

So the brain is happily deriving energy from ketones – sure, but why would this be protective against such a variety of brain diseases?

One answer may be energy. Despite their superficial differences, many neurological diseases share one major problem – deficient energy production. During metabolic stress, ketones serve as an alternative energy source to maintain normal brain cell metabolism. In fact, BHB (a major ketone) may be an even more efficient fuel than glucose, providing more energy per unit oxygen used. A ketogenic diet also increases the number of mitochondria, so called “energy factories” in brain cells. A recent study found enhanced expression of genes encoding for mitochondrial enzymes and energy metabolism in the hippocampus, a part of the brain important for learning and memory. Hippocampal cells often degenerate in age-related brain diseases, leading to cognitive dysfunction and memory loss. With increased energy reserve, neurons may be able to ward off disease stressors that would usually exhaust and kill the cell.

A ketogenic diet may also DIRECTLY inhibit a major source of neuronal stress, by –well- acting like a blueberry. Reactive oxygen species are unfortunate byproducts of cellular metabolism. Unlike the gas Oxygen, these “oxidants” have a single electron that makes them highly reactive, bombarding into proteins and membranes and wrecking their structure. Increased oxidants are a hallmark of aging, stroke and neurodegeneration.

Ketones directly inhibit the production of these violent molecules, and enhance their breakdown through increasing the activity of glutathione peroxidase, a part of our innate anti-oxidant system. The low intake of carbohydrates also directly reduces glucose oxidation (something called “glycolysis”). Using a glucose-like non-metabolized analogue, one study found that neurons activate stress proteins to lower oxidant levels and stabilize mitochondria.

Due to its high fat nature, keto increases poly-unsaturated fatty acids (PUFAs, such as DHA and EPA, both sold over-the-counter as “brain healthy” supplements), which in turn reduces oxidant production and inflammation. Inflammatory stress is another “root of all evil”, which PUFAs target by inhibiting the expression of genes encoding for pro-inflammatory factors.

Neurons on Ketones: Dampen that enthusiasm!

Excited neurons transmit signals, process information and form the basis of a functioning brain. OVER-excited neurons tend to die.

The brain teeters on a balance between excitation and inhibition through two main neurotransmitters, the excitatory glutamate and the inhibitory GABA. Tilt the scale towards glutamate, which occurs in stroke, seizures and neurodegeneration, and you get excitotoxicity. In other words, hyper-activity is toxic.

Back in the 1930s, researchers found that direct injection of various ketone bodies into rabbits prevented chemically-induced seizures through inhibiting glutamate release, but the precise mechanism was unclear. A recent study in hippocampal neurons showed that ketones directly inhibited the neuron’s ability to “load up” on glutamate – that is, the transmitter can’t be packaged into vesicles and released – and thus decreased excitatory transmission. In a model of epilepsy that used a chemical similar to glutamate to induce damage, the diet protected mice against cell death in the hippocampus by inhibiting pro-death signaling molecules. On the other end of the excitation-inhibition balance, ketones increase GABA in the synapses (where neurotransmitters are released) of rats and in the brains of some (but not all) epileptic humans subjects. This increase in inhibition may confer both anti-seizure effects and neuroprotection, though data is still scant.

Then there are some fringe hypotheses. The acidity of ketones may decrease the pH of certain brain microdomains, which might be the mechanism of keto’s positive effect on Type II Bipolar disorder (lots of mays and mights, I know). As keto affects the whole body, global changes due to calorie restriction and regulation of the satiety hormone Leptin are bound to alter brain function, and play a circumstantial role.

Neuroprotection? Show me the evidence!

All these molecular changes suggest that a ketogenic diet is protective against brain injury. But is there any REAL evidence?

A study with 23 elderly with mild cognitive impairment showed that a ketogenic diet improved verbal memory performance after 6 weeks compared to a standard high carbohydrate diet. In a double-blind, placebo-controlled study, 152 patients with mild- to moderate Alzheimer’s disease were given either a ketogenic agent or a placebo, while maintaining a normal diet. 90 days later, those receiving the drug showed marked cognitive improvement compared to placebo, which was correlated with the level of ketones in the blood.

In a pilot study in 7 patients with Parkinson’s disease, 5 were able to stick to the diet for 28 days and showed marked reduction in their physical symptoms. In an animal model of Amytrophic Lateral Sclerosis (ALS), a ketogenic diet also led to delayed motor neuron death and histological and functional improvements, although it did not increase life span; clinical trials are on the way.

Remarkably, a long-term ketogenic diet does not seem to be associated with significant side effects, although constipation, dehydration and electrolyte and micronutrient deficiencies are common complaints. More serious complications include increased chance of kidney stones, gallbladder problems and bone fractures, especially in children. Menstrual irregularities often occur in women, with potential impact on fertlity. Although ketoacidosis – acidification of the blood due to pathological levels of ketones – was historically proposed as a side effect, nutritional ketosis simply cannot achieve the level of ketones required to induce this life-threatening state. Nevertheless, there are no studies directly monitoring the side effects of ketosis yet, hence it’s too early to conclude that the diet is completely safe for everyone.

Brain <3 Bacon?

While promising, large-scale placebo-controlled clinical trials in patients with neurological disorders are still lacking. The existing data needs to be interpreted carefully to avoid generating false hope or encourage patients to “ditch drugs for diet”. Nevertheless, the possibility that we can reduce symptoms of untreatable neurological disorders through modifying dietary composition is quite incredible; that a ketogenic diet may benefit physical and cognitive performance in healthy individuals is an even more tantalizing idea.

As the science behind this age-old dietary therapy gradually comes to light, social issues such as low adherence and public prejudice will need to be resolved. In the meantime, to those neuroscientists interested in studying keto: pass the bacon and I VOLUNTEER!

Final note: Before I let you go, I’d like to stress again that keto is NOT something to try out without talking to your doctor first, nor is it a replacement for pharmaceuticals. There’s simply not enough evidence, on either its effectiveness or side effects. Nevertheless, it’s a cool area of research to keep an eye on!

~~~~

Related at Scientific American:

The other selfie: a single case study experiment on “clean eating”
The Marketing Diet: Want to lose weight? Give up Marketing.
Human Ancestors Were Nearly All Vegetarians
How to Really Eat Like a Hunter-Gatherer: Why the Paleo Diet Is Half-Baked

Shelly Fan About the Author: Shelly Xuelai Fan is a PhD Candidate in Neuroscience at the University of British Columbia, where she studies protein degradation in neurodegenerative diseases. She is an aspiring science writer with an insatiable obsession with the brain. She mulls over neuroscience, microbiomes and nutrition over at Neurorexia. Follow on Twitter @ShellyFan.

The views expressed are those of the author and are not necessarily those of Scientific American.

Tags:






Comments 7 Comments

Add Comment
  1. 1. jdege 7:09 pm 10/1/2013

    “Normally, human bodies are sugar-driven machines.”

    Actually, that’s not even close to being true. Normally, human bodies burn predominantly sugar only immediately after meals, or during periods of intense, anaerobic exercise. The rest of the time, you’re mostly burning fat.

    Remember that “fat-burning zone” people keep talking about? If you work harder than that, you’ll be burning mostly sugar. In the zone, and below, you’re burning mostly fat. That is, if you’re metabolically healthy.

    Infants live in ketosis until their weaned. Every healthy adult spends much of the night in ketosis. It’s not an unusual state.

    If you’re burning sugar throughout most of your day, you’re either severely insulin resistant, diabetic, or you’re eating sugar and starch way too often (and likely will be insulin resistant and then diabetic, soon.)

    Link to this
  2. 2. Bill_Lagakos 7:14 pm 10/1/2013

    Anecdotally speaking, there are a lot of positive reports about ketogenic diets and cognitive function. They deserve much greater attention from the scientific community.

    Link to this
  3. 3. Pasturedbeef 12:14 am 10/2/2013

    I was diagnosed at age 5 as ADHD (I think it was just labelled ADD or Hyperactive at the time) and was forced to go on Ritalin until the age of 11. Those 6 years on Ritalin may have set the stage for my insulin resistance and carbohydrate intolerance. I first learned about ketosis 4 years ago through a friend who introduced me to The Protein Power Lifeplan by Drs. Michael and Mary Dan Eades. I devoured that book in a couple of days and before I even finished reading it I was throwing food in the garbage. Anything with wheat, Gone! Sugar, Gone! Transfats, soy, Gone! Corn Starch, Gone! Modified this or that, Gone! I began reading everything I could to improve my health, I began reading Blogs from Jimmy Moore, Gary Taubes, Jay Wortman, Sean Croxton, and many others, and when I didn’t have time to read I’d listen to their podcasts while commuting to work. I’ve been in and out of ketosis over these last 4 years, which helped me shed 110lbs and over 15 inches off my waist. After just the first few weeks of fat adaptation, I was able to throw away my asthma inhalers and acid reflux medication. I find I don’t get headaches any more, and my sinus is as clear as ever. I noticed my mental clarity has greatly improved, and I am much more able to focus on tasks. I’ve done a lot of experimenting, measuring ketones and blood sugar levels with various foods and find my body prefers to be in ketosis because I am at my healthiest, my immune system is rock solid and my athletic performance is greatly enhanced. Just imagine how different things would have turned out for me if my parents had not allowed me to have sugary breakfast cereals, and instead fed me bacon and eggs before I went to school. Nutritional Ketosis is far healthier for me, than fueling my body with carbs.

    Link to this
  4. 4. Bryant H 12:33 am 10/2/2013

    Thank you for this article. A few times I have adopted a ketogenic diet and never felt better (and lost weight, lowered BP…). Nutrition is a complex subject and the sooner we replace old dogma with scientific study the better. I’m a physicist and love the quantified self movement. I think we could organize and take the “nurses health study” to a new quantitative level.

    Link to this
  5. 5. larkalt 2:42 pm 10/2/2013

    Gluten can have a lot of psychiatric and neurological effects, so I wonder how often, when a ketogenic diet helps, that’s due to the person being gluten-sensitive – since the ketogenic diet would usually be gluten-free.

    Link to this
  6. 6. spotty 3:04 pm 10/2/2013

    “we don’t yet know the side effects of a long-term ketogenic diet.”

    Whereas we DO know the long-term effects of a non-ketogenic government-endorsed AHA/ADA-approved diet … obesity, diabetes, heart disease, the legion of issues that stem with gluten sensitivity, and now, dementia!

    Link to this
  7. 7. spotty 3:11 pm 10/2/2013

    And being snarky but IS a nice blog post. Despite the obligatory CYA.

    Link to this

Add a Comment
You must sign in or register as a ScientificAmerican.com member to submit a comment.

More from Scientific American

Scientific American Holiday Sale

Limited Time Only!

Get 50% off Digital Gifts

Hurry sale ends 12/31 >

X

Email this Article

X