April 19, 2013 | 4
April 19, 1770 British Captain James Cook reached for the first time the south-eastern coast of Australia. The continent of Australia had been “discovered” by Europeans already in 1606, but only in 1642 the size of the new “island” was realized. However the first geological descriptions of the new continent happened only at the beginning of the 19th century.
October 1800 two ships – the “Geographe” and the “Naturaliste” – set sail from the harbor of Le Havre, France. Under the command of Captain Nicolas Baudin (1754-1803) geographers, astronomers, artists, naturalists, zoologists, botanists, and 2 mineralogists – Louis Depuch (1774-1803) and Charles Bailly (1777-1844) – were instructed to explore, map and eventually claim for France new territories of this new world. In the last moment also the young zoologist, and trained paleontologist, Francois Auguste Peron (1775-1810) joined the expedition.
The geological observations made by Depuch (died during the expedition) are known from various reports send to Baudin. Bailly will publish some notes after his return to France and Peron included his research in the official report of the expedition.
In May 27, 1801 the bare land of Cape Leeuwin was in sight and the naturalists went on land along the Wonnerup Inlet, where they collected the first specimens of Australian animals, plants and rocks.
Fig.1. The “Baudin” – expedition, route drawn on Louis de Freycinet´s (1779-1842) “Carte générale de la Nouvelle Hollande”, published in 1811 as part of the results of the 1800-1804 expedition (image in the public domain).
A storm forced the men to remain on land for several days and one man died during a failed attempt to reach the ships (during the entire expedition 32 men died, 13% of the crew, a surprising low percentage considering the period). The storm separated the two ships, the “Naturaliste” proceeded to the island of Timor, a Dutch colony at the time, where the crew fell ill with Malaria and other tropical diseases. The “Geographe” approached in November 1801 the island of Tasmania, where the expedition will stay for three months.
April 1802 the “Geographe” meet the British vessel “Investigator“. The expedition of the “Investigator” will map large parts of South-Australia and prove that Australia is one large continent, not two islands separated by a sea strait, as some geographers assumed. This was a disappointing discovery for captain Baudin, as there was no apparent geographic separation between the territories already claimed by British explorers, the entire continent had to be considered of British domain.
Captain Baudin, the crew and the naturalists could now only hope to gain some fame with the scientific results of the expedition.
Depuch and Bailly used a rock classification scheme, developed by the famous French geologist Déodat de Dolomieu, with four categories. They recognized primary rocks, such as granite; secondary rocks, such as stratified sandstone and limestone; alluvium (recent deposits) and volcanic rocks, such as basalt. The presence of these rocks in Australia was an important discovery, it proved that the classification scheme developed in Europe could be applied worldwide.
Fig.2. Charles-Alexandre Lesueur´s and Nicolas-Martin Petit´s depiction of Van-Diemen´s-Land for the “Voyage de decouvertes aux Terres Australes“. The two young men – unskilled workers at the beginning of the expedition - were invited by Baudin to illustrate the logbook - both will become the most skilled artists for animal- and plantlife of the time. The granitic rocks found on the island of Tasmania convinced Peron and the other geologists that the most ancient – the primary – rock was Granite, forming the basement of all continents (image in public domain).
Peron noted along the west coast of Australia horizontal sand- and limestone layers (the Tamala-Limestone) and concluded, based on similarities to recent sediments, that these layers were deposited along an ancient beach, implying substantial variations in the sea level during geologic time:
“One of the greatest achievements of modern geology research and also one of its most indisputable, is the certain knowledge that, in the past, the level of the sea was higher than at the present time. At almost all places in the old and the new world is the proof of this phenomenon as numerous as it is evident. Only in les Terres australes was this still to be ascertained as, by virtue of its immense areal extent, it could have proved to be an important exception to the universality of the former domination of the ocean over the land.” (PERON & FREYCINET 1816)
Unfortunately the return to France will be disappointing for Peron. Captain Baudin dies on the island of Timor and French authorities will show little interest in the 220.000 samples of animals, plants and rocks, the 73 living animals, 3 kangaroos, 2 emus and 3 wombats brought back to Europe.
Peron publish his report “Voyage de decouvertes aux Terres Australes” only in 1807, after a long struggle for money and dies just three years later, before the completion of the second volume. However the sea shells collected during the expedition will be studied by an important French naturalist – Jean-Baptiste de Lamarck. In 1804 Lamarck publishes his theory about the transmutation of species, based in part of the observation that the fossil shells found in the sediments of France are similar, but not identical, to shells of living molluscs collected in Australia.
Fig.3. Peron discovers on the shores of Tasmania a living clam with a peculiar triangular shape – Trigonia antarctica – a genus of bivalve known only from fossils found in the sediments of the basin of Paris. He notes the similarities of this living specimen with fossil specimens – an important step to consider a relationship between fossil and extant species. Trigonia sp. from Cretaceous sediments of Bavaria.
Unfortunately for Lamarck – and the naturalists of the Baudin expedition – he mixed his careful observations with wild speculations. Lamarck noted variations of organisms in time, however he could not explain why such variations occur or why certain organisms went extinct or survived – apart invoking a final cause and implying a supernatural scheme. Geologist Charles Darwin will later regard Lamarck’s work as “useless“.
GLAUBRECHT, M. & MERMET, G. (2007): Josephines Emu oder Die Geschichte einer vergessenen Expedition. GEO Nr.6/2007: 98-122
MAYER, W. (2008): Early geological investigations of the Pleistocene Tamala Limestone, Western Australia. from GRAPES, R.H.; OLDROYD, D. & GRIGELIS, A. (eds) History of Geomorphology and Quaternary Geology. Geological Society, London, Special Publications 301: 279-293
MAYER, W. (2009): The Geological Work of the Baudin Expedition in Australia (1801-1803): The Mineralogists, the Discoveries and the Legacy. Earth Sciences History Vol.28 (2): 293-324
RUDWICK, M.J.S. (2005): Bursting the limits of time – The reconstruction of Geohistory in the Age of Revolution. The University of Chicago Press, Chicago, London: 708