ADVERTISEMENT
  About the SA Blog Network













Guest Blog

Guest Blog


Commentary invited by editors of Scientific American
Guest Blog HomeAboutContact

It’s about Time: Animals remember past events in their lives

The views expressed are those of the author and are not necessarily those of Scientific American.


Email   PrintPrint



This is the first part of a two-post series. The Part 2 is at The Thoughtful Animal blog on our network.

“Let’s see if you bastards can do ninety.” And with that, the DeLorean accelerated forwards and traveled back in time thirty years.

Unfortunately, in life outside Back to the Future, we do not yet have the option of time travel. The closest thing we have at the moment is mental time travel. As humans, we have the ability to let our minds wander back in time to an experience of our choice, whether it be thirty years, or thirty minutes.

The ability to remember a particular event or episode (so-called ‘episodic memory’) is not the only type of memory we have. We also have memory of facts of the world, for example, ‘the sky is blue’, or ‘Jack Bauer is a hard man’, without having a specific episode in mind – we just seem to know it.

Episodic memory is considered to be a key aspect of our consciousness. Indeed we find it difficult to imagine being ourselves without our personal memories. This topic has not only captivated philosophers and science fiction writers; it is also a large field in science. One area has been to try and learn whether other animals apart from humans have memories of past events in their lives. Apart from it being an interesting question in itself, knowing this could help us better appreciate human episodic memory, and aid our understanding of diseases which affect it (like Alzheimer’s).

But how do we go about finding out if other animals remember events from their past? In humans, we have a simple way of doing this: we ask. Unfortunately with non-human animals it is not so easy. First, we have to think about what specifically we mean by an ‘episodic memory’. Endel Tulving, the godfather of episodic memory, said that it was a form of consciousness that allows people to think about the subjective time in which they live and ‘mentally travel’ in that time. Unfortunately this definition is somewhat futile when coming to test it in other animals. More recently two scientists, Nicola Clayton and Anthony Dickinson, proposed a new definition of episodic memory in order to look for it in non-human animals. This definition was that the behaviour would have to fit three criteria: the animal must have the ability to recall ‘what, where and when’; to integrate this information; and then deploy this information flexibly.

As this is quite a lot of information to take in in one go, let us break down that last sentence. Firstly, when we recall a memory from our past, say, our first date, the key components of that memory are ‘what’, ‘where’ and ‘when’. The ‘when’ part of the memory would be, say, fifteen years ago. The ‘where’ part of the memory might be an ice cream parlour (yes I am lapsing into an American Hollywood movie cliché). And perhaps the ‘what’ part of the memory is that the date was really awkward and it finished with you concluding that the opposite sex were not all they were cracked up to be. However, we don’t recall these three separate pieces of information as separate entities: they are all integrated as a whole.

This brings us to the second of Clayton and Dickinson’s criteria that an episodic memory has to fulfill: the memory must be an integrated whole (not just where and when it was, or what and where it was). The final criterion an episodic memory must adhere to is that it must be able to be deployed flexibly in new situations. For example, we can recall an event from the past, and use that information to apply it to a new situation given our current knowledge about the world. This is something we do countless times a day, perhaps without even realizing it.

Now that we have broken down episodic memory into its composite parts it is certainly more attainable than a vague sense of our memories in a wispy floaty form. However, it is still difficult to see how it might be demonstrated in non-human animals.

Clayton and Dickinson tackled this challenge through an innovative set of experiments with western scrub jays. A key thing to know about these birds is a particular natural behaviour they have: they store food (by burying it) to retrieve at a later date. To begin with, the researchers gave birds the opportunity to learn about different types of food. They were given peanuts and wax worms to bury in sand-filled ice cube trays, and then dig up at a later date. During this training phase the birds learned that the worms (which they greatly preferred) decayed much faster than the peanuts. They therefore also learned that if a long period of time had passed then there was not much point in digging them up, as they had gone rotten.

The birds were then tested in a scenario where they were given new ice cube trays where they were forced (by restricting access to one side of the tray) to store one type food on one side of the tray, and then the other type of food on the other side of the tray five days later. Four hours after they buried the second food type they were allowed to dig up both of the food items.

The order in which they were allowed to store the two food items differed. This meant that when worms were stored first they would have decayed by the time the birds recovered the food. However, when the nuts were stored first both foods would still be edible. The birds behaved as if they remembered what they had done: when they buried the worms first, then the nuts five days later, they recovered the nuts and ignored the rotten worms. However, when they buried the nuts first, and their favourite wormy snack was still fresh, they dug that up instead.

So it seems that these birds remembered ‘what’ food was buried (the peanuts or the wax worms), ‘where’ they buried it (the location in the ice tray), and ‘when’ they did so (four hours or five days previously). They also integrated these three components into a single memory, as not doing so would have resulted in them making mistakes when digging up the stored food.

However, there was a possibility that the birds were not remembering, but simply using a visual cue or smell to choose which part of the tray to dig for food. To make sure this was not the case, another test was carried out. This time the birds were allowed to store their food in the ice cube tray as before, but when the tray was presented to them the second time, the food was removed and it was filled with clean sand. The birds dug in the places that they would have found the food if it had not been removed by the researchers, and did so in the same pattern as before: digging for nuts when the worms were old, and for worms when they were fresh.

Even though this was fairly convincing evidence for an episodic type of memory in scrub jays, there was still another possible way that the birds could have been solving the task. Perhaps they were just not as good at remembering worms as peanuts. This would mean that when the birds stored the worms first, it was not that they were purposefully avoiding them when they had decayed: they had just forgotten about them.

To make sure this was not the case, a second group of scrub jays were trained on worms which, after they were buried by the birds, were always dug up by the scientists (without the birds seeing) and replaced with fresh worms. This meant that these birds never learned that worms decayed over time. When these birds were tested, they always dug up the worms more often than the nuts, even when more time had elapsed. This shows that the first group of birds were indeed avoiding the worms because they had learned that they had decayed, and not just because scrub jays forget worms more easily.

So, scrub jays did seem to integrate the ‘what-where-when’ information into an ‘episodic-like’ memory. It is called ‘episodic-like’ because we can never truly prove that an animal is remembering the past in a similar manner to how we remember it, even if they show all the same behavioural signs. Some might argue that since this is the case, we may as well just call it ‘episodic’ and be done with it, but that can be for the philosophers to worry about.

You may remember that there was a third criterion for episodic memory: the ability to use memories flexibly in new situations. This means integrating an episodic memory with a knowledge-about-the-world type memory like ‘the sky is blue’. For example, you might remember exactly which pub you left your lucky hat in last night, but then you later learn from a friend that you looked like a bit of an idiot in that hat, and everyone was laughing at you most of the time anyway. You might have been going to retrieve your hat, but now that you have integrated this new knowledge about it (and more importantly, how you look wearing it), you decide on balance it is probably not worth retrieving.

So, what would be an example of this in the bird world? Say a scrub jay stores some worms, but then after having buried them learns separately that worms degrade more quickly than it originally thought. This second part of information is not stored in the original episodic memory, but is more general knowledge about the world. Can a scrub jay then use its memory and this new knowledge to change its behaviour? It was found that the scrub jays could: when they buried food but then learned from another store they had that those worms had degraded faster than expected, they then changed their preference in the original tray to the nuts.

These experiments are exemplary because they not only were the first conclusive evidence for episodic-like memory in non-human animals, they also are a good demonstration of the scientific method in action. Initially the scientists found that birds seemed able to remember food-storing episodes in their lives. However, they then addressed all the possible caveats they could think of in their original experiment, or the ways that they could disprove their finding. The follow-up experiments held up their original result and made it even more convincing.

Photo credits:

Time: Carlos Henrique Reinesch

Western Scrub Jay: Cory Chen

References:

Clayton, N., Yu, K. & Dickinson, A. (2001) Scrub jays (Aphelocoma coerulescens) form integrated memories of the multiple features of caching episodes. Journal of experimental psychology. Animal behavior processes 27(1): 17.

Clayton, N.S., Bussey, T.J. & Dickinson, A. (2003) Can animals recall the past and plan for the future? Nature Reviews Neuroscience 4(8): 685-691.

Clayton, N.S. & Dickinson, A. (1998) Episodic-like memory during cache recovery by scrub jays. Nature 395(6699): 272-274.

Clayton, N.S. & Dickinson, A. (1999) Scrub jays Aphelocoma coerulescens remember the relative time of caching as well as the location and content of their caches. Journal of Comparative Psychology 113(4): 403.

Tulving, E. (1985) Memory and consciousness. Canadian Psychology/Psychologie Canadienne 26(1): 1.

Now, proceed to Part 2 of this post, over at The Thoughtful Animal blog.

Felicity Muth About the Author: Felicity Muth is an early-career researcher with a PhD in animal cognition. Follow on Twitter @notbadscience.

The views expressed are those of the author and are not necessarily those of Scientific American.






Comments 63 Comments

Add Comment
  1. 1. cat 4 brother 9:41 pm 01/15/2015

    Woman of Alien…

    Best operate you’ve got finished, this page is de facto awesome with superb data. Time is God’s way of holding all the things from taking place directly….

    Link to this
  2. 2. Memoria: alcune cose da sapere (e ricordare) - Nuovo e Utile | Teorie e pratiche della creatività. 3:39 am 01/19/2015

    [...] Già: anche gli animali hanno una memoria, topolini di laboratorio compresi. Gli scienziati indagano la memoria degli animali, anche se farlo non è semplicissimo perché non li si può certo intervistare sui loro ricordi. [...]

    Link to this
  3. 3. alkaline water 9:08 pm 01/21/2015

    The Absent Game…

    Involving me and my husband we have owned a lot more MP3 players over time than I can count, such as Sansas, iRivers, iPods (classic & touch), the Ibiza Rhapsody, etc. But, the last few a long time I’ve settled down to one line of gamers….

    Link to this
  4. 4. water ionizer comparisons 1:29 am 01/22/2015

    Third Flower…

    My spouse and i happen to be now delighted that Albert could perform his research thanks to the ideas he had by your website. It is now and again perplexing to just constantly be gifting away techniques which a lot of people might have been advertising…

    Link to this
  5. 5. hay day tips 8:15 pm 01/22/2015

    The Ships’s Voyages…

    I feel know-how just can make it even worse. Now there is a channel to never ever treatment, now there won’t be considered a opportunity for them to discover….

    Link to this
  6. 6. wrtruyjgvgcszbrdr 12:08 pm 02/10/2015

    Title…

    [...]we came across a cool web-site that you simply could love. Take a look when you want[...]…

    Link to this
  7. 7. alkaline water 8:40 pm 02/13/2015

    Woman of Alien…

    Excellent work you’ve got finished, this page is basically interesting with excellent facts. Time is God’s method of retaining every thing from occurring at the same time….

    Link to this
  8. 8. Long 2:17 am 02/14/2015

    Title…

    [...]here are some links to web-sites that we link to since we think they may be worth visiting[...]…

    Link to this
  9. 9. Maduras 3:54 am 02/14/2015

    Title…

    [...]please take a look at the sites we adhere to, such as this 1, as it represents our picks through the web[...]…

    Link to this
  10. 10. videos xxx 9:13 am 02/14/2015

    Title…

    [...]below you will uncover the link to some sites that we assume you need to visit[...]…

    Link to this
  11. 11. Porno 11:28 am 02/14/2015

    Title…

    [...]one of our guests not too long ago recommended the following website[...]…

    Link to this
  12. 12. insurance auto 1:27 pm 02/15/2015

    Title…

    [...]Wonderful story, reckoned we could combine a handful of unrelated information, nonetheless actually worth taking a search, whoa did a single master about Mid East has got far more problerms also [...]…

    Link to this
  13. 13. bdswiss 3:43 pm 02/15/2015

    Title…

    [...]Here are a few of the websites we suggest for our visitors[...]…

    Link to this
  14. 14. videos gays 11:47 pm 02/15/2015

    Title…

    [...]very couple of internet sites that come about to become in depth beneath, from our point of view are undoubtedly well worth checking out[...]…

    Link to this
  15. 15. home 12:08 am 02/16/2015

    Title…

    [...]although websites we backlink to below are considerably not connected to ours, we really feel they’re basically worth a go via, so have a look[...]…

    Link to this
  16. 16. home 3:45 am 02/16/2015

    Title…

    [...]very handful of web sites that happen to be detailed below, from our point of view are undoubtedly effectively worth checking out[...]…

    Link to this
  17. 17. Check Out Your URL 5:13 pm 02/16/2015

    Title…

    [...]that would be the finish of this write-up. Here you will uncover some sites that we feel you’ll value, just click the links over[...]…

    Link to this
  18. 18. social media in advertising 5:22 pm 02/16/2015

    Title…

    [...]check below, are some absolutely unrelated web sites to ours, having said that, they are most trustworthy sources that we use[...]…

    Link to this
  19. 19. online dating site for free 5:41 pm 02/16/2015

    Title…

    [...]here are some hyperlinks to internet sites that we link to mainly because we consider they’re really worth visiting[...]…

    Link to this
  20. 20. follow us on social media 6:40 pm 02/16/2015

    Title…

    [...]Every as soon as inside a although we opt for blogs that we study. Listed beneath would be the latest web pages that we choose [...]…

    Link to this
  21. 21. have a peek at this web-site 10:12 pm 02/16/2015

    Title…

    [...]one of our guests just lately advised the following website[...]…

    Link to this
  22. 22. singles chat 3:36 am 02/17/2015

    Title…

    [...]Here is an excellent Weblog You may Discover Interesting that we Encourage You[...]…

    Link to this
  23. 23. click this link now 10:32 am 02/17/2015

    Title…

    [...]although web sites we backlink to beneath are considerably not related to ours, we feel they may be basically really worth a go via, so have a look[...]…

    Link to this
  24. 24. interracial online dating 10:55 am 02/17/2015

    Title…

    [...]always a huge fan of linking to bloggers that I really like but do not get quite a bit of link really like from[...]…

    Link to this
  25. 25. young girls dating older men 11:13 am 02/17/2015

    Title…

    [...]very couple of web sites that come about to be detailed beneath, from our point of view are undoubtedly well worth checking out[...]…

    Link to this
  26. 26. videos porno 1:49 pm 02/17/2015

    Title…

    [...]Here are some of the web pages we advise for our visitors[...]…

    Link to this
  27. 27. free instagram followers no survey 2014 1:49 pm 02/17/2015

    Title…

    [...]usually posts some really fascinating stuff like this. If you are new to this site[...]…

    Link to this
  28. 28. social media for business marketing 3:27 pm 02/17/2015

    Title…

    [...]very handful of web-sites that happen to be in depth below, from our point of view are undoubtedly well worth checking out[...]…

    Link to this
  29. 29. click here to find out more 4:39 pm 02/17/2015

    Title…

    [...]Sites of interest we’ve a link to[...]…

    Link to this
  30. 30. social network search 4:50 pm 02/17/2015

    Title…

    [...]although internet sites we backlink to below are considerably not associated to ours, we really feel they may be basically really worth a go via, so have a look[...]…

    Link to this
  31. 31. videos porno 5:32 pm 02/17/2015

    Title…

    [...]Wonderful story, reckoned we could combine some unrelated data, nevertheless definitely worth taking a search, whoa did one particular study about Mid East has got much more problerms as well [...]…

    Link to this
  32. 32. przedszkole-roza.pl/?p=136 11:57 pm 02/17/2015

    Title…

    [...]here are some hyperlinks to web-sites that we link to simply because we consider they may be really worth visiting[...]…

    Link to this
  33. 33. Lamoa 6:12 am 02/18/2015

    Title…

    [...]usually posts some extremely interesting stuff like this. If you are new to this site[...]…

    Link to this
  34. 34. Recommended Reading 2:08 pm 02/18/2015

    Title…

    [...]Wonderful story, reckoned we could combine several unrelated data, nevertheless definitely worth taking a search, whoa did a single understand about Mid East has got additional problerms too [...]…

    Link to this
  35. 35. kangen 7:42 pm 02/18/2015

    Third Flower…

    My spouse and that i happen to be now delighted that Albert could execute his scientific studies as a consequence of the suggestions he had as a result of your website. It can be once in a while perplexing to only always be freely giving methods which …

    Link to this
  36. 36. anti wrinkle tips in hindi 1:17 am 02/19/2015

    Title…

    [...]Every after inside a when we opt for blogs that we study. Listed below would be the most up-to-date internet sites that we select [...]…

    Link to this
  37. 37. http://usprepper8.livejournal.com/profile 4:46 am 02/19/2015

    Title…

    [...]always a huge fan of linking to bloggers that I appreciate but really don’t get a great deal of link appreciate from[...]…

    Link to this
  38. 38. read review 5:01 am 02/19/2015

    Title…

    [...]one of our guests just lately suggested the following website[...]…

    Link to this
  39. 39. kitchen remodeling the woodlands 12:28 am 02/20/2015

    Title…

    [...]the time to study or pay a visit to the material or web sites we have linked to below the[...]…

    Link to this
  40. 40. employment history background check 4:41 am 02/20/2015

    Title…

    [...]Sites of interest we’ve a link to[...]…

    Link to this
  41. 41. tragamonedas 10:53 pm 02/20/2015

    The Ships’s Voyages…

    I think technological innovation just can make it even worse. Now there’s a channel to never care, now there will not likely be considered a prospect for them to discover….

    Link to this
  42. 42. kangen water 7:07 pm 02/22/2015

    The Ships’s Voyages…

    I feel technological know-how just can make it even worse. Now there is a channel to by no means care, now there will not be considered a likelihood for them to discover….

    Link to this
  43. 43. Check Out Your URL 10:43 pm 02/22/2015

    Title…

    [...]the time to study or stop by the content or sites we’ve linked to below the[...]…

    Link to this
  44. 44. Yajaira 10:51 pm 02/22/2015

    Title…

    [...]Sites of interest we have a link to[...]…

    Link to this
  45. 45. bikini beach bunny 11:21 pm 02/22/2015

    Title…

    [...]Here are several of the websites we advise for our visitors[...]…

    Link to this
  46. 46. videos xxx 12:58 am 02/23/2015

    Title…

    [...]we came across a cool internet site that you just could enjoy. Take a look when you want[...]…

    Link to this
  47. 47. decoraciones para baby shower de ni�a con mariposas 2:26 am 02/23/2015

    Title…

    [...]just beneath, are numerous absolutely not connected web-sites to ours, nevertheless, they are certainly really worth going over[...]…

    Link to this
  48. 48. kingsford waterbay price 9:24 am 02/23/2015

    Title…

    [...]Here is an excellent Blog You might Obtain Interesting that we Encourage You[...]…

    Link to this
  49. 49. best low cost autoresponder 2:33 pm 02/23/2015

    Title…

    [...]although internet websites we backlink to below are considerably not related to ours, we really feel they may be truly really worth a go by way of, so have a look[...]…

    Link to this
  50. 50. Google 9:30 pm 02/23/2015

    Google…

    Every after inside a when we decide on blogs that we study. Listed below would be the most current web pages that we select….

    Link to this
  51. 51. sexo casero 5:24 am 02/24/2015

    Title…

    [...]Sites of interest we’ve a link to[...]…

    Link to this
  52. 52. site here 8:03 pm 02/24/2015

    Title…

    [...]usually posts some extremely exciting stuff like this. If you’re new to this site[...]…

    Link to this
  53. 53. benzodiazepines uk 8:57 pm 02/24/2015

    Thorn of Girl…

    Superb data may be discovered on this world wide web blog site….

    Link to this
  54. 54. best buy fashion bracelets 1:12 am 02/25/2015

    Title…

    [...]Here is a superb Blog You may Come across Exciting that we Encourage You[...]…

    Link to this
  55. 55. bk-2c-b 2:06 am 02/25/2015

    The Slave of the Husband…

    Trying to find forward to finding out added from you afterward!……

    Link to this
  56. 56. botanique at bartley showflat 11:02 am 02/25/2015

    Title…

    [...]Every as soon as inside a though we decide on blogs that we read. Listed beneath would be the most up-to-date web-sites that we choose [...]…

    Link to this
  57. 57. browse around here 7:27 pm 02/25/2015

    Title…

    [...]very handful of internet websites that occur to be in depth below, from our point of view are undoubtedly nicely really worth checking out[...]…

    Link to this
  58. 58. new handheld selfie stick monopod 12:39 am 02/26/2015

    Title…

    [...]one of our visitors a short while ago proposed the following website[...]…

    Link to this
  59. 59. Pregnancy Calculator 4:50 am 02/26/2015

    Title…

    [...]that is the end of this report. Here you’ll find some web sites that we consider you will appreciate, just click the links over[...]…

    Link to this
  60. 60. buy nifoxipam 9:27 pm 02/27/2015

    Thorn of Girl…

    Great info is often found on this world wide web blog site….

    Link to this
  61. 61. instagram followers buy real 2:03 am 02/28/2015

    Title…

    [...]Every after inside a although we pick blogs that we read. Listed beneath are the most recent internet sites that we select [...]…

    Link to this
  62. 62. methiopropamine 2:12 am 02/28/2015

    Thorn of Girl…

    Excellent data could be discovered on this world wide web blog….

    Link to this
  63. 63. Westwood ec 4:15 pm 02/28/2015

    Title…

    [...]very couple of internet websites that come about to be comprehensive beneath, from our point of view are undoubtedly well worth checking out[...]…

    Link to this

Add a Comment
You must sign in or register as a ScientificAmerican.com member to submit a comment.

More from Scientific American

Scientific American Holiday Sale

Scientific American Mind Digital

Get 6 bi-monthly digital issues
+ 1yr of archive access for just $9.99

Hurry this offer ends soon! >

X

Email this Article

X