ADVERTISEMENT
  About the SA Blog Network













A Blog Around The Clock

A Blog Around The Clock


Rhythms of Life in Meatspace and Cyberland
A Blog Around The Clock Home

Myths about myths about Thanksgiving turkey making you sleepy

The views expressed are those of the author and are not necessarily those of Scientific American.


Email   PrintPrint



Does tryptophan from turkey meat make you sleepy?

Short answer is NO.

Long answer is much, much more interesting than what you usually hear.

You have probably heard or read two types of contradictory stories:

In one type of story, eating a lot of turkey meat makes you sleepy. It is wrong in its conclusion because it makes (at least) two assumptions wrong.

In the other type of story, eating a lot of turkey meat does not make you sleepy. Its conclusion is correct, but not for the right reasons – it still (even the best article I could find) is likely to contain at least one erroneous assumption.

Both types of stories rely on the same underlying mechanism of how, potentially, this could work, based on what we know about human physiology. But both are ignoring (or are not aware) of a mechanism that is much more plausible. Turkey does not end up making you sleepy only due to that one little factoid that pro-sleepy stories get wrong and anti-sleepy stories get right.

Let’s dissect this story, then. What are the essential lines that all (pro and con) stories have?

A) Tryptophan is an essential amino acid that we get from food. Tryptophan is a biochemical precursor of serotonin, i.e., our bodies convert tryptophan into serotonin in the brain.

B) Serotonin makes you sleepy.

C) More there is tryptophan in the body, more serotonin will be produced in the brain.

D) Since turkey meat has lots of tryptophan, eating it will result in sleepiness.

Pro-sleepy stories make all four assumptions. All four are wrong.

Most anti-sleepy stories make two or three of those four assumptions, thus they get at least one of them right. What the anti-sleepy stories usually get right is that D) is incorrect -  it is a myth that turkey meat has much tryptophan. It actually has only about 509mg per 200-Calorie serving and is thus quite an average food (some other foods served at Thanksgiving may contain more tryptophan than turkey does).

At least some of the anti-sleepy stories also figure out that B) is wrong. Serotonin may make you happy or confident, but it cannot make you sleepy. Those articles get something important right: the amino-acid tryptophan is a precursor of neurotransmitter serotonin which in turn is the precursor of hormone melatonin. It is melatonin that makes you sleepy.

Here it is in a simplified shorthand:

What really derails both the pro-sleepy and anti-sleepy stories is the insistence that this all has to happen in the brain – the combined statements A) and C).

So they spend some time and effort figuring out how all that postulated extra tryptophan could possibly get into the brain. And that’s hard – tryptophan does not passively pass the blood-brain barrier but is imported by a molecular carrier. The same carrier also transports other amino-acids. Thus one would have to ingest incredible amounts of pure tryptophan, no other molecules included, and somehow trick the carriers to transport all of the tryptophan into the brain, for this to work.

Once in the brain, that tryptophan would supposedly be turned into serotonin, and then serotonin would be turned into melatonin inside of the tiny pineal gland in the brain.

It appears that not everyone knows that all the enzymes needed for synthesis of melatonin (from tryptophan, via serotonin) can be found and are active in places other than just the pineal organ.

Conversion of tryptophan, via serotonin, to melatonin also happens in the retina of the eye, in the Harderian gland (located in the ocular orbit just behind the eyeball), and in the intestine.

The intestine has a large and complex semi-independent nervous system (“The Second Brain” of sensationalist reports) in which most or all of the same neurotransmitters and hormones are found as in the brain.

Actually, more melatonin is produced in the intestine than in all the other sites combined.

Normally, intestinal melatonin plays a role in control of gut motility – peristalsis – and perhaps some other local functions.

In most species intestinal melatonin gets degraded within the intestine. In other words, little or no melatonin ever leaves the intestine and leaks into the bloodstream.

Also, depending on the species, melatonin in the intestine is predominantly synthesized either during the day, or during the night, or continuously (Serotonin N Transferase enzyme is the “rate-limiting” enzyme in the pathway you see above in the picture, and it is under direct control of the circadian clock). In humans, it appears that some intestinal melatonin (not much, though) leaks into the bloodstream at all times, and that most of the synthesis happens during the day.

What happens if one ingests incredibly large amounts of pure tryptophan (not just tryptophan-rich food, where other molecules may interfere with the process)?

Interestingly, it has been shown in rats and chickens that adding extra tryptophan can promote synthesis of extra melatonin. In other words, the enzymes do not get saturated or down-regulated by extra tryptophan. Either there is a lot of enzymes already there, capable of processing extra tryptophan fast, or (we don’t know yet) the enzymes may even get up-regulated by the tryptophan load.

In studies in which rats and chickens were loaded with huge amounts of pure tryptophan, extra melatonin leaks from the intestine into the bloodstream even if it normally does not do so in that particular species.

Other studies show that melatonin secreted from the intestine does not in any way affect the levels of melatonin synthesis in other locations (pineal, eye). If there is more melatonin, it came from the gut.

Melatonin does not require any carriers or transporters to cross the blood-brain barrier. No matter where it was originally produced, it easily enters the brain. Once there, it can produce sleepiness either directly or by acting on the circadian clock. It has long been known that increasing levels of melatonin in the bloodstream can phase-shift the circadian clock, place the phase into the night, and thus promote the feeling of sleepiness.

So, what anti-sleepy stories get right (and pro-sleepy stories get wrong), is that turkey is a weak agent for this. One would need enormous amounts of pure tryptophan to get an effect.

What both types of stories get wrong is their insistence that this has to happen in the brain. That is a wrong mechanism to look at – blood-brain barrier guards against extra tryptophan, so no amount of extra loading can do the trick.

But a huge load of tryptophan (how about a gallon of saturated solution poured directly into your stomach via gastric gavage?) could have the effect, and easily so, if one knows that all that extra tryptophan would first be converted into melatonin in the intestine itself, then easily pass into the brain. The mechanism is much more plausible, it is just that the turkey meat is incapable of triggering it.

So, why are you sleepy at the end of Thanksgiving dinner? You are tired of all that travel, cooking, hugging family, watching football, serving and eating… You are overstimulated. You may have had some alcohol with your meal. And look at the clock – it’s almost bed-time anyway.






Comments 4 Comments

Add Comment
  1. 1. promytius 11:55 pm 11/23/2011

    Of COURSE turkey makes you sleepy, Jerry Seinfeld showed us how it worked on his girlfriend so he could play with her GI Joe toy collection while she slept off the turkey.
    Happy Thanksgivings Day.

    Link to this
  2. 2. Bora Zivkovic 11:58 pm 11/23/2011

    LOL. I’d love to read the paper by Seinfeld et al. – do you have the DOI or link?

    ;-)

    Link to this
  3. 3. BMardle 2:46 am 11/24/2011

    It seems to me that if melatonin is produced in the body from serotonin, and melatonin makes you sleepy, then (in a sense) serotonin does make you sleepy.

    Over the past 10 years I’ve been prescribed 4 serotonin re-uptake inhibitors for depression. I often felt light-headed on 3 of those (sometimes sleepy, sometimes dizzy, sometimes couldn’t tell). From speaking to others I gather that that’s a common side effect.

    (I’m currently on a tricyclic antidepressant, allegedly the most sedating (and most serotonergic) one… It doesn’t make me light-headed.)

    Link to this
  4. 4. Bora Zivkovic 1:21 pm 11/24/2011

    Serotonin and melatonin often have opposite effects. Thus, the enzyme sNAT (the second enzyme in the pathway in the figure) serves as an ON/OFF switch.

    Examples:

    Inside the eye, serotonin and melatonin have opposite effects on the shape (length) of the rods and cones, with serotonin adapting the eye to day-vision, and melatonin to night-vision. Melatonin also drives the process of disk-shedding of rods and cones, something that is better done during the night while one is asleep.

    In the brain, serotonin is important during the day while we are awake, to keep us going. At night, darkness perceived by the eyes sends signals to the SCN (suprachiasmatic nucleus) in the hypothalamus which becomes active. One of the outputs is an adrenergic (using nor-epinephrine as a neurotransmitter) neural pathway to the pineal gland, where it upregulates sNAT, resulting in production of melatonin. Melatonin leaks out of the pineal into the brain and into circulation, preparing our brain and body for sleep. When the light comes back on, this means it’s day (so time to to get up and do some work), or that moon is so bright that nocturnal predators can see us better, so it is better to sleep lightly or be awake, so sNAT shuts down, so melatonin synthesis shuts down.

    In the intestine, sNAT is regulated by the local (‘peripheral’) circadian clock located in the gut. It upregulates sNAT during the day, leading to most of the tryptophan being moved to melatonin which slows down gut movement (peristalsis) as digestion is less important during the day when one needs to be active and agile. At night, sNAT is downregulated, most of the tryptophan ends up as serotonin which speeds up peristalsis so we can digest better during sleep.

    It is a nifty mechanism for regulation of two similar molecules that have opposite effects and opposite duties inside of our bodies.

    Link to this

Add a Comment
You must sign in or register as a ScientificAmerican.com member to submit a comment.

More from Scientific American

Scientific American Dinosaurs

Get Total Access to our Digital Anthology

1,200 Articles

Order Now - Just $39! >

X

Email this Article

X